November 18th marks International #CultAwarenessDay—a day to remember the victims of Jonestown and other high-control groups, while educating ourselves on the realities of coercive control.
We can't fight what we don't understand. To help spread critical awareness today, we are asking our community to step up:
Create your own graphics highlighting the signs of psychological manipulation and cultic abuse.
Share graphics from trusted resources to help educate your network.
Use the hashtag #CultAwarenessDay on everything you post to build a unified message.
By raising our voices together, we can protect vulnerable people and support those on their journey to recovery.
In an episode of NBC’s Dateline titled Blindsided, Brandon Boudreaux recounted surviving an assassination attempt and expressed enduring remorse over the death of Charles Vallow. Charles, who was Lori Vallow’s fourth husband, had tried to warn Boudreaux about Lori’s escalating involvement in an apocalyptic cult before Charles was fatally shot by Lori’s brother, Alex Cox, in July 2019.
Boudreaux explained that he had missed earlier calls from Charles because his estranged wife, Melani Pawlowski, had allegedly deleted the messages. Although Boudreaux eventually reached out to apologize for not offering greater support, Charles was killed only weeks later. In October 2019, Boudreaux himself survived a drive-by shooting in Gilbert, Arizona, when a gunman fired at his vehicle.
Investigators linked the vehicle used in the ambush to Lori Vallow’s family, forcing Boudreaux into hiding with his children for months. In 2025, juries convicted Lori of conspiracy to commit murder against both Charles Vallow and Brandon Boudreaux, concluding a protracted investigation into violent offenses tied to her religious group.
Kenyan prosecutors informed the Mombasa High Court that cult leader Paul Mackenzie continued spreading apocalyptic doctrines from inside prison while awaiting sentencing for murder. Authorities stated that Mackenzie utilized contraband mobile phones and SIM cards registered to fellow inmates at Shimo La Tewa Maximum Security Prison to direct co-defendants and instruct followers to starve themselves to death.
The allegations surfaced during the trial of Mackenzie and seven co-accused individuals concerning the discovery of 28 bodies in shallow graves at Kwa Binzaro in Kilifi County. An inmate serving a 50-year term testified that he had several registered SIM cards to access mobile loans, one of which he used to transfer money to Mackenzie.
Prison wardens and criminal investigators uncovered hidden phones, notes, and Bibles with contact directories inside the facility. Mackenzie was convicted alongside 28 accomplices for the murders of 191 people, including 190 children, connected to the Shakahola forest starvation tragedy that shocked the nation.
Controversial cult leader Paul Mackenzie is set to serve his 200-year prison sentence in strict isolation to prevent him from radicalizing other inmates. Interior Cabinet Secretary Kipchumba Murkomen announced that the Kenyan government has established a specially segregated detention arrangement specifically designed to neutralize any risk of the preacher spreading his extremist ideology within the correctional system. This decisive measure follows troubling reports that Mackenzie actively attempted to indoctrinate law enforcement officers and fellow detainees prior to his formal imprisonment.
Under these exclusive custody conditions, Mackenzie will be entirely separated from the general prison population. While he retains his fundamental constitutional rights and remains subject to standard judicial procedures, prison officials will closely monitor his communications, visitor access, and daily routine to thwart any recruitment efforts.
Meanwhile, residents of Kilifi County are demanding accountability from local chiefs and administrators. Community members argue that authorities blatantly ignored obvious warning signs—including mass school dropouts and migrations to the Chakama Ranch—that preceded the Shakahola forest tragedy, which ultimately claimed over 400 lives.
Paul Mackenzie, the founder of the Good News International Church, has been sentenced to 200 years in prison by the Mombasa High Court for his role in the deaths of 191 people, including 190 children. The court found that Mackenzie held primary criminal culpability for orchestrating a mass starvation campaign in eastern Kenya's Shakahola Forest. He had convinced his followers to abandon their homes and fast to death in order to "meet Jesus" and prepare for heaven.
Justice Diana Mochache emphasized that the severe sentence was necessary to reflect the gravity of the atrocities committed. The ruling followed the discovery of over 400 bodies in shallow graves in 2023, which sparked global outrage and a massive criminal investigation. Prosecutors originally sought the death penalty, noting Mackenzie's lack of remorse.
Mackenzie and his co-conspirators claimed the deaths were voluntary, but witness testimonies revealed a brutal reality. Followers who resisted the forced fasting directives were beaten or threatened with violence. Over two dozen accomplices were also sentenced for their participation in the deadly religious movement.
Dan Mackenzie, the son of convicted doomsday cult leader Paul Mackenzie, has publicly shared how a childhood refusal to follow his father's religious teachings ultimately saved his life. Following his father's landmark 200-year prison sentence in Mombasa for the starvation deaths of 190 children and one adult, Dan explained that his early rebellion kept him away from the deadly Shakahola forest settlement.
Paul Mackenzie, the founder of the Good News International Church, had relocated his followers to a remote forest in 2019. He established a highly controlled community where modern medicine and education were banned as "satanic." Followers were instructed to fast to death to reach heaven, while enforcers beat or threatened those who resisted.
While many in the local Furunzi village welcomed the 200-year sentence and the permanent closure of Mackenzie's church, some extended family members in Machakos County rejected the court's findings. They maintained his innocence, claimed the verdict was influenced by public opinion, and announced their intentions to appeal the conviction.
The devastating 1978 Jonestown massacre in Guyana and the recent Shakahola tragedy in Kenya serve as grim warnings about the catastrophic consequences of doomsday cults. Despite occurring decades apart, both events share alarming parallels, notably the isolation of followers, the absolute authority of charismatic leaders, and the tragic deaths of hundreds of children and adults.
In Jonestown, American preacher Jim Jones led over 900 followers of the Peoples Temple to their deaths through a forced, cyanide-laced drink. Decades later, Kenyan pastor Paul Mackenzie of the Good News International Church manipulated his followers into starving themselves to "meet Jesus," resulting in hundreds of recovered bodies in the Shakahola forest. Mackenzie was recently sentenced to 200 years in prison for the murder of 191 people.
Both tragedies reveal a systematic pattern of coercive control, apocalyptic teachings, and physical isolation that prevented victims from escaping. These mass casualty events highlight the urgent need for authorities to investigate credible allegations of religious abuse before vulnerable followers are subjected to life-threatening manipulation.
The National Bureau of Investigation in Central Visayas placed a 16-year-old into state custody after uncovering an online extremist group accused of grooming minors to execute mass shootings and other violent offenses. Regional Director Dominador Cimafranca stated that the Cebu-based teenager served as an administrator of a digital chat group that glorified school attacks, weapons, and graphic material.
Federal agents initiated the inquiry in August following intelligence alerts from international partners regarding imminent school violence. A search warrant executed at a residence in Barangay Kamputhaw led to the confiscation of multiple digital devices. Investigators found that the group cultivated personal trust with youngsters before introducing them to private forums promoting extremism, AI-generated abusive imagery, and planned livestreams of violence.
The juvenile suspect was transferred to the Department of Social Welfare and Development to determine discernment under the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act. Officials used the case to urge closer parental supervision over gaming platforms and social channels.
Recent research indicates that up to one-third of adults in the United States have experienced some form of religious trauma or spiritual abuse, with the LGBTQ community being disproportionately affected.
Many individuals who exit high-control faith environments develop Religious Trauma Syndrome (RTS). This debilitating condition emerges as people struggle to recover from authoritarian religious indoctrination, often centered around dogmatic purity cultures, divine wrath, and intense fear of judgment.
Author Michael Camp notes that toxic churches frequently rely on domineering leadership styles that demand absolute obedience while actively suppressing sincere theological questions. Congregants are pressured to conform entirely to the group's worldview, leading to an "us-versus-them" mentality that demonizes outsiders.
When members finally begin to deconstruct their faith or challenge harmful teachings, they often face severe social retaliation. The resulting psychological damage can include anxiety, depression, complex PTSD, and profound relational alienation. Bringing awareness to these destructive patterns is a crucial first step in helping survivors heal from the lasting scars of institutional spiritual abuse.
A local reporter went undercover to investigate the Society of St Pius X Resistance (SSPXR), a religious sect based in Broadstairs, Kent. Founded by the late Richard Williamson, a convicted Holocaust denier and prominent conspiracy theorist, the group continues to operate from a former guest house on the Thanet coast.
Posing as a lapsed Catholic, the journalist recorded disturbing conversations with members and clergy. During his visits, the reporter documented instances of extreme antisemitism, including a worshipper declaring that a former synagogue in Margate should be "burned to the ground." Furthermore, "Father" Stephen Abraham, the main priest in residence, openly repeated Holocaust denial theories, claiming Jewish people had created a "mythology" around the historical atrocity.
The undercover investigation also highlighted the group's political connections, noting the involvement of a former British National Party (BNP) parliamentary candidate and discussions referencing Third Positionism, a movement widely regarded as neo-fascist. Despite Williamson's death, the SSPXR continues to attract new followers through its online presence, circulating extreme rhetoric that the mainstream Catholic Church firmly rejects.
AI Research Disclosure: To bring you the most relevant stories, parts of this newsletter utilize artificial intelligence (AI) tools to search the web, source articles, and assist with content curation. This content is for informational purposes only; we recommend verifying critical facts independently.
The articles selected for CultNEWS101 do not imply that Patrick Ryan, Joseph Kelly, or Ashlen Hilliard endorse the content. We provide information from multiple perspectives to foster dialogue.
Netflix’s upcoming documentary, Primetime Preacher$, explores the explosive 1980s rivalry among three of America’s most prominent televangelists: Jim Bakker, Jimmy Swaggart, and Jerry Falwell. Directed by Academy Award nominee Joe Berlinger and produced by Jason Bateman, the film examines how these charismatic figures built massive international broadcasting empires in God's name.
The documentary highlights how these religious leaders transformed evangelical Christianity from a largely nonpartisan movement into a formidable political force in the United States. Experts in the film note that Bakker and his wife, Tammy Faye, popularized a more entertaining, less somber approach to faith through their multimillion-dollar PTL Club program.
However, the narrative takes a dark turn as it explores the spectacular collapse of Bakker’s religious empire in 1987. A highly publicized sex and financial fraud scandal, sparked by allegations of sexual assault by Jessica Hahn, ignited a bitter "holy war" among the three preachers. Through archival footage and firsthand accounts, the film investigates the profound intersection of faith, ambition, and media manipulation.
"When I left cultic churches/religion behind in 1995, I decided to train as a counselor with the specific aim of helping others leaving similar situations, because at the time there was no one (yes, no one!) who was a trained therapist able to work effectively with these issues.
Now, after years of training, research and clinical work, I train other therapists with lived experience to work with the Walking Free Model: Counselling for Coercive, Cultic and Spiritual Abuse, the model I created."
A number of therapists worldwide have now completed the Certificate in the Walking Free Model and work with it very effectively.
The feedback is that the model is helpful, and we are seeing people recover and heal.
Applications are now open for the 2027 training.You can apply now, before the 21 November 2026 deadline.
After spending two decades inside the Church of Scientology, Anne Gollert Hill is publicly sharing her journey of escape, newfound freedom, and personal reinvention. Hill recently detailed her experiences on The Creative Entrepreneur Podcast, exploring the organization's intense psychological environment and the specific red flags that ultimately led her to question its authority.
Since leaving, Hill has successfully reclaimed her personal narrative and leveraged her content creation skills to build a massive online platform. In her mid-60s, she has amassed an impressive 1.3 million TikTok views, showing that authentic storytelling and lived experience can powerfully resonate with global digital audiences. Her growing visibility even caught the attention of prominent figures like Jenny McCarthy, who invited Hill onto her own podcast.
Refusing to let her past dictate her future, Hill is currently preparing to release her upcoming memoir, Escape to Joy. Her story serves as a testament to resilience, encouraging others to break free from toxic environments and boldly rebuild their lives at any age.
In a recent family law case, the Massachusetts Appeals Court has issued its first interpretation of the state's newly amended 2024 coercive control statute. The landmark decision in Kehlani K. v. Tripp T. clarifies that physical violence is not necessary to secure an abuse prevention order. Instead, a documented pattern of controlling behavior, surveillance, and unwanted intrusions can justify a protective order on its own.
The ruling focused on a husband who continuously monitored his estranged wife's whereabouts during a contentious divorce. The Appeals Court determined that actions such as tracking her location and repeatedly showing up unannounced at public and private venues constituted a severe violation of autonomy. The court emphasized that a reasonably reduced sense of autonomy is sufficient grounds for protection, even without the imminent threat of physical harm.
Furthermore, the decision established that a perpetrator's intent can be inferred directly from their circumstantial conduct, eliminating the need for explicit proof of intent. While the court left open the exact number of acts required to establish a pattern, the ruling provides a crucial legal roadmap for identifying and litigating coercive control in future Massachusetts family law disputes.
A Kenyan court has sentenced Paul Mackenzie, the leader of a doomsday cult, to 200 years in prison after finding him guilty of murdering 191 people, including 190 children and one adult. The convictions relate to a mass starvation scheme in which Mackenzie instructed followers to deprive themselves and their children of food so they could “meet Jesus.”
Mackenzie, a self-proclaimed pastor and leader of Good News International Church, was arrested in 2023 following the discovery of hundreds of bodies in shallow graves in Shakahola Forest, near Kenya’s coast. The investigation exposed the devastating consequences of his teachings and attracted international attention.
The court imposed separate 100-year sentences for homicide and offenses related to starvation. Mackenzie was tried alongside 28 other defendants, who were also convicted in connection with the deaths.
The case has raised serious questions about religious authority, institutional oversight, and protecting vulnerable individuals from coercive practices. The sentencing represents a significant development in Kenya’s efforts to hold those responsible for the Shakahola tragedy accountable.
Lead prosecutor Jami Yamina has formally petitioned a Kenyan court to impose the death penalty on cult leader Paul Mackenzie. Mackenzie and 28 co-defendants face sentencing on Friday, November 6, for the murders of 190 children and one adult discovered in Kenya’s Shakahola forest.
The prosecution has requested life imprisonment for 27 other defendants, along with a separate sentencing proposal for Enos Amanya Ngala following his guilty plea. These differing recommendations reflect central questions running through the judicial proceedings about how responsibility should be apportioned between the religious leader and the followers who carried out his instructions.
A source familiar with the case characterized presiding Justice Diana Kavedza as an abolitionist opponent of the death penalty. More surprisingly, the insider suggested Mackenzie might receive neither capital punishment nor a life term, potentially facing a determinate prison sentence, though the judge has not yet delivered her ruling or legal reasoning.
The prospect of a fixed prison term raises pressing concerns over judicial proportionality, victim justice, and the broader legal standards governing religious extremism in Kenya.
The Church of Scientology International has officially purchased a historic building in San Francisco's Financial District to expand its local footprint. The organization acquired the three-story property, historically known as the Bartlett Building, for $2.2 million. Located near the Church’s existing headquarters, the site dates back to 1908 and adds about 10,000 square feet to its operations.
Before this acquisition, attempts to redevelop the long-neglected Sacramento Street property into co-living housing ultimately stalled. The building's earlier revitalization efforts were derailed by the global pandemic and a broader economic downturn affecting downtown San Francisco. Despite these past setbacks, the property recently underwent extensive renovations.
Looking ahead, the Church of Scientology intends to preserve the building's historic architectural features while adapting the interior spaces to meet its organizational needs. This real estate transaction underscores a continued trend of religious and spiritual organizations investing in prominent Bay Area properties, signaling shifting dynamics in the city's commercial real estate market.
The historic Reid-Longworth building at 211 W. Fourth Street in downtown Cincinnati is currently undergoing a massive $14.7 million rehabilitation. Led by the Model Group, this 52,000-square-foot renovation is a key component of the broader $37 million "Fourth and Rhine" initiative. This extensive project aims to revitalize ten historic buildings across the city's downtown and Over-the-Rhine neighborhoods.
Expected to be completed in late 2027, the structure will eventually offer 37 apartments ranging from studios to two-bedroom units. The developers emphasize that these apartments will serve as "workforce" housing, specifically targeting individuals earning between 60% and 120% of the area's median income. By avoiding high-end luxury amenities, the project successfully maintains reasonable rental rates while delivering high-quality residential spaces.
Constructed in 1868, the building features a uniquely diverse history. It previously served as a saddlery, a furniture showroom, a hotel, and most recently, a Church of Scientology, before the property was sold in 2012. Developers are now reviewing options for the commercial spaces, preferring a cafe or similar downtown services.
AI Research Disclosure: To bring you the most relevant stories, parts of this newsletter utilize artificial intelligence (AI) tools to search the web, source articles, and assist with content curation. This content is for informational purposes only; we recommend verifying critical facts independently.
The articles selected for CultNEWS101 do not imply that Patrick Ryan, Joseph Kelly, or Ashlen Hilliard endorse the content. We provide information from multiple perspectives to foster dialogue.
Social scientists and scholars of high-tension religious groups (often referred to as new religious movements or emergent religious groups) have spent nearly half a century debunking the social psychological theory of “brainwashing.” But there is now a veritable brainwashing legal renaissance in child protection guidelines in Japan, several US states, and the UK through the concept of “coercive control.” In this exploratory perspective piece, we trace the ideological lineage of mid-century anti-cult rhetoric into twenty-first-century childcare and child protection frameworks. We argue that the legal doctrine and cultural logic of parens patriae, one means by which the state regulates and mandates the construction of care, is increasingly weaponized to regulate parental religious socialization under the guise of psychological safeguarding, building upon Japanese anti-cult educational guidelines and the American OneTaste trafficking legal case precedent. We hope that this brief discussion pushes back on recent international appetite for the suppression of “deviant” religious liberty within the family unit.
1. Introduction
In this article, we argue that the increased use of “coercive control” rhetoric among psychologists, sociologists, criminologists, and other scholars of violence and religion presents challenges that have not been addressed. Namely, coercive control and related concepts like brainwashing and mind control have a long and polemical history in the field of religious studies pertaining to what many call “new religious movements” (NRMs). In this article, we seek to elaborate on the history of this term and its usage among scholars and other interested parties, primarily in Japan, the United States, and the United Kingdom (for other geographic contexts like Australia, see Doherty (2026d); for former Soviet states, see the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (2020); and for Argentina, see Introvigne (2026a, 2026b)).
The 2026 conference of the International Cultic Studies Association featured about 28 items on its schedule, including speaker sessions and panels, directly or indirectly referring to the concept of “coercive control.” This concept has seemingly become more relevant to the work of many scholars, including cultic studies scholars. We find it necessary to cast a critical eye on this concept: How could coercive control impact the lives of members of new religious movements (or what we term “high-tension religions” or “emergent religious groups”—see Bromley and Melton (2012); Foertsch (2022, 2025); Foertsch and Yang (2026)) Although we do not present exact answers to this question, we hope to encourage more critical thought and consideration of coercive control and its various applications.
Recently, governments in Japan, the United States, and the United Kingdom have passed legislation or guidelines against coercive control. The legal concept of parens patriae is particularly relevant to these legal precedents. Here, we seek to examine these statutes and related court cases to better determine how this concept can be used to affect the lives of members of high-tension religions materially and legally. To begin, this article will briefly detail the history of the concept of coercive control and related ideas like brainwashing, mind control, and deprogramming. Then, we examine statutes and court cases in Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United States that directly relate to coercive control law. We argue that coercive control law, though potentially useful against individuals conducting IPV, should not be used against groups of people, particularly high-tension religious groups, following the work of scholars such as Introvigne (2026a, 2026b).
2. Brainwashing, Deprogramming, and the Anti-Cult Movement
Although the concept of brainwashing predates the Cold War, in the 1950s, the United States experienced a great panic over brainwashing. Starting with (supposed) CIA agent Edward Hunter’s accounts of American prisoners of war in China soon after the Korean War, brainwashing was heavily associated with communism (Hoesly 2026; Parker 2021; Introvigne 2026a). The history of this concept is beyond the scope of this paper; however, we agree with Eileen Barker when, in 1984, she wrote that “We cannot assume that because the Unification Church [or any other new religious movement] is a bad/wrong/ill-conceived/incomprehensive movement, its membership can be recruited only by mind-control deception” (Barker 1984, pp. 7–8).
Soon, though, brainwashing would be extensively used to describe the activities of high-tension religious groups like the Unification Church, the Church of Scientology, and the Children of God (now The Family International). It was through his son’s interactions with the Children of God that compelled Ted Patrick to invent the practice known as deprogramming in the late 1960s and early 1970s (Parker 2021; Ushiyama 2019). Deprogramming is the practice of hiring someone to essentially “unbrainwash” someone. Most of the time, deprogramming is done against members of high-tension religious groups like the Unification Church, but as Parker (2021) shows, deprogrammers occasionally deprogram people for queer sexual orientation (similar to those conducting “conversion therapy” on gay and transgender people) and political affiliations. Many cases of deprogramming include the use of kidnapping, false imprisonment, and food, water, and sleep deprivation. This is because deprogrammers believe that to undo the brainwashing one must use the same or similar techniques.
Patrick and other disgruntled parents formed what would eventually become the Cult Awareness Network (CAN), which was the leading anti-cult and cult awareness organization in the United States until its eventual bankruptcy in 1996 through various lawsuits with members of the Church of Scientology and other NRMs. The CAN had a referral kickback system that propped up many deprogrammers, including Ted Patrick (Shupe and Darnell 2006). When someone would call in to the CAN for help with a member of a high-tension religion (or any affiliation that the caller does not like), the CAN would refer them to a deprogrammer. When the deprogrammer was eventually paid, they would kick back some of the money to the CAN, creating a sort of deprogramming syndicate.
Many scholars of new religious movements raised ethical concerns over the frequency of deprogrammings in the United States from the late 1970s through the early 1990s. However, only once the CAN filed for bankruptcy—and its files and other assets were bought up by wealthy members of the Church of Scientology—did deprogramming become very infrequent in the United States.1
During this same time, an ongoing debate—sometimes called the “Cult Wars”—was raging in American and British academies. On one side, many sociologists of religion, historians of religion, and religious studies scholars rejected brainwashing as an explanation for the rise of membership in high-tension religious groups in the 1960s and 1970s (see, e.g., Barker (1984), Bromley and Richardson (1983), and Introvigne (2022)). On the other, some psychologists, psychiatrists, and sociologists believed that brainwashing had its merits for explaining this new religious phenomenon. These debates culminated into two distinct fields of study: the field of new religious movement (NRM) studies and cultic studies. Support for the “brainwashing thesis,” as NRM studies scholars have termed it, is the key difference between the two fields of study (Parker 2021). Generally, NRM studies scholars reject brainwashing as an explanation for membership in NRMs, whereas cultic studies scholars are more likely to believe that brainwashing—or something similar like “thought reform”—are central to explaining NRM membership.
A few cultic studies participants were also deprogrammers, namely, Steven Hassan and Rick Alan Ross (Parker 2021; Introvigne 2026c). However, because of various lawsuits (particularly from Scientologists) against deprogrammers, Hassan and Ross changed their practices to avoid the more harmful activities of deprogramming like false imprisonment and kidnapping. Thus, a “non-coercive” form of deprogramming emerged called exit counseling, one example of which being Steven Hassan’s BITE model, through which he developed what he calls the “Strategic Interaction Approach” (Hassan 2020; Introvigne 2026c). The core goal of this activity, however, is the same as deprogramming: disaffiliate whoever is being counseled from an identity (usually from a high-tension religion).
Coercive control narratives have been used to study high-tension religious groups since the 1970s. In 1979, Susan Andersen and Philip Zimbardo (the psychologist behind the Stanford Prison Experiment) produced a technical research report to the Office of Naval Intelligence at Stanford University. “Cults” and “coercive control” are among the keywords in this report, which suggests methods of reducing “susceptibility to unwanted coercive control” (Andersen and Zimbardo 1979). Sessions and Doherty (2021) cover the history of the term “coercive control” in cultic studies scholarship to the present, which we feel no need to reproduce in detail here.
3. Coercive Control
Coercive control has been used as a concept to better understand battered women and IPV contexts, largely in the “feminist pathways” criminological literature (see Mallicoat (2019) for a good overview). Typically found in heterosexual relationship couplings and within the context of patriarchy, applying these standards can be seen as a gross overinflation of the original analytic object to group coercive control, hypothetically discovered in high-tension religious groups. This slippage is analytically and conceptually precipitous, because it takes a framework developed from a typical dyadic scenario rooted in the structurally enabled abuses of patriarchy and applies it to vastly different religious groups that have radically different conceptions of gender norms, sexuality norms, individual regulation level, childrearing practices, etc. A blanket application of the categories found in typical coercive control measures in academic studies (such as what is found in Raghavan and Doychak (2025)) and legal codes becomes a massive conceptual overreach that must be pushed back against in the context of high-tension religions.
Coercive control-like abuse certainly could happen in the context of high-tension or minority religions, but that does not mean that the full group should be held guilty of coercive control. As a court would not condemn the entire Catholic Church for the pedophilic tendencies of one priest, one cannot condemn the entire religious group for coercive control mechanics potentially found within its membership. Within the legal framework of coercive control as used in the context of high-tension religions, the law would need to focus on holding accountable the specific leaders or intimate partners that perpetrate this type of abuse, typically captured within more established legal and evidentiary precedent, rather than immediately moving to criminalize religious behaviors through the conceptually open-ended coercive control parameters that are now developing and being legally codified.
While there are no doubt instances in which abuse happens through coercion, our contention is that coercive control could be propagated in US courts to further the anti-cult “brainwashing” thesis, which has widely been considered debunked by sociologists and religious studies scholars for decades (Introvigne 2026a, 2026c). The recent rise in cultural hegemonic normativity associated with the growing influence of state integralist movements (such as Christian nationalism and Christofascism; see Foertsch (2026a, 2026b); Foertsch and Pieper (2023); Foertsch et al. (2024); Foertsch and Dougherty (2025); Py (2020, 2021a, 2021b); Whitehead and Perry (2020); Gorski and Perry (2022); Stewart (2022)), as well as a form of assertive secularism that decries religious “abuse,” has created a perfect storm that in other countries led to a strong deprogramming movement (especially in Japan, South Korea, France, etc.—see Introvigne (2026b); Duval (2026); Ushiyama (2019); Parker (2025); Tanaka (2026)). This alliance of evangelical integralists and secular anti-religionists creates the strong conditions for the codification of deprogramming into the corpus of law, which then takes on an influence of its own.
Coercive control laws are typically relegated to civil cases in the United States, which are on the books in Connecticut, California, Massachusetts, and Colorado. Related to our topic, parental fitness is determined to resolve custody disputes. Lawyers aligned with the anti-cult movement (on either partisan side) could use evidence of non-physical manipulation, such as financial manipulation, isolation, and surveillance (Santo 2025), to argue for religiously motivated abuse (Duval 2026; Introvigne 2026b).
Hawaii is currently the only state to have criminalized coercive control, which occurred in 2021 (Hawaii Revised Statutes 2025), making it a charge in criminal cases. It is considered a petty misdemeanor. The statute defines coercive control as “a pattern of behavior that seeks to take away the individual’s liberty or freedom and strip away the individual’s sense of self” (Hawaii Revised Statutes 2025). Not soon after, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill 1141 allowing coercive control to be used as an explanation for seeking civil protective orders (Stuart 2025). State lawmakers in Washington tried and failed in 2021 to also make it a criminal gross misdemeanor (Washington State Legislature House 2021), and a bill is pending in New York to make it a felony (New York State Legislature 2025) (Santo 2025). As one may have noticed, the wording of these definitions is quite vague. State legislatures throughout the United States have a clear interest in civilly and criminally punishing coercive control in IPV contexts, but some are attempting to use coercive control in the regulation of religion. The work of Sarah Feliciano (Feliciano 2023; Feliciano et al. 2020; Feliciano and Raghavan 2025) represents the latest attempts at bridging the concepts of cult and coercive control,2 in addition to the recent surge in scholarship from the International Cultic Studies Association connecting “cults” and coercive control.3
4. Legal Precedent and Court Cases Regarding Coercive Control
4.1. Parens Patriae
Parens patriae is a legal principle that was established in the English Middle Ages and became part of the Common Law tradition (Clark and Katz 2021; Wadlington et al. 2026). It originally referred to the monarch’s role as a father to all his subjects in the country. Eventually, it morphed into the legal role of the state as the ultimate “parent of last resort,” where the state assumes the role of the parent when no other guardian is immediately competent and forthcoming (Ingram and Ryals 2020, pp. 1–2). This legal principle was used in the creation of the juvenile justice system in the late nineteenth century. The first juvenile court act was passed in Illinois in 1899 (Springer 1986, p. 20). Called The Act to Regulate the Treatment and Control of Dependent, Neglected, and Delinquent Children, it established the first dedicated juvenile court in the nation, which established parental surrogacy: “This act shall be liberally construed, to be the end that its purpose may be carried out, to-wit: That the care, custody, and discipline of a child shall approximate as nearly as may be that which should be given by parent” (Ingram and Ryals 2020, p. 2).
In contemporary America, the parens patriae doctrine makes it the state that ultimately judges who is or is not a competent parent, and once deemed insufficient, usurps the familial function from the family unit and displaces it into the state (historically the absolutist sovereign, now the nation-state collectivity). This is one of the basic starting points of the intrusion of the state into what Habermas (1985) would call the lebenswelt after Husserl (1970), where the everyday life of the individual is slowly colonized by the state apparatus.
The legitimate use of violence upon the individual (Weber 1978; Foucault 1995), which is granted to the state asymmetrically through the biopolitical power dominance structure (Foucault 1995), creates a situation in which the parental role is usurped by the state at the threat of violence. In many cases, this extrication is a necessary role that the state must play out to protect those who cannot protect themselves. Nevertheless, parens patriae as legal and cultural logic (Bourdieu 1986, 1992; Enfield 2000) creates the continued condition for the intervention of the state into the individual family unit, a situation that is ripe for potential misuse. Parens patriae allows the state to construct conditions of care that may prove harmful to vulnerable populations like children, women, and queer people. Coercive control laws, then, are founded on these principles, in which the state is the ultimate “parent” to its subjects, and are one of many legal apparatuses of the construction of care that may harm vulnerable groups. Coercive control law, especially when coercive control is categorized as a criminally punishable offense, requires strict, unambiguous delineations, as we argue; otherwise, it would allow the state to hamper religious freedom rights for members of high-tension religious groups in favor of normativity.
4.2. Religious Abuse and Deprogramming in Japanese Public Schools
Japan is a hallmark case of how coercive control and child protection legal guidelines can develop if unchecked (Introvigne 2026b). In Duval’s (2026) article “Unification Church in Japan: After the Dissolution, the Purge,” the parens patriae governmentality (Foucault 1978) is found in full blush in Japanese anti-cult guidelines adopted by the government after influence from secular anti-cult activists.
The guidelines published by the Japanese Government Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare on 27 December 2022 argue that “making a child attend religious services when they do not feel like it or participate in religious activities constitutes ‘psychological abuse,’ and that imprinting continuous fear since childhood through verbal reprimands or references to ‘hell’ constitutes child abuse.” (Duval 2026, p. 39). The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (an entity whose mandate the United States no longer recognizes, as of February 2025) interceded to remind the Japanese government that this is a dangerous lower threshold of establishing abuse in religious settings (Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights 2025).
The goal in the Japanese context is to “de-indoctrinate” and “re-educate” second-generation (children) believers away from their parents’ faith using the public school system (Duval 2026, pp. 35–37). As such, the government uses anti-cult language as guidelines for teachers, school staff, and counselors (Duval 2026, pp. 40–43) as they meet with students to ascertain whether there is “religious abuse” afoot (“child abuse related to religious belief”—see Duval 2026, pp. 32, 35), in a striking example of a violation of freedom of conscience and religious association (see Article 18 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights; United Nations General Assembly (1948)).
These policy guidelines utilize the state role as a parent of last resort (otherwise known as the legal principle of parens patriae) to position the state in between the parent and child during the process of religious socialization. As we can see in the Japanese context after the disbandment of the Unification Church due to the assassination of former President Shinzo Abe, the role of the state in child protection becomes a forceful systemic function of asserting hegemonic religious normativity.
4.3. United States Human Trafficking Laws and the OneTaste Case
In the United States, the anti-cult movement has inserted its basic elements (namely, Hassan’s (2020) BITE model) into legal precedent regarding the protection of women, which will undoubtedly be used to foster children reprogramming. This legal precedent, found mostly in cases on human trafficking, is the legal precedent that Hassan himself has been desperate to establish (Introvigne 2026a).4
In 1988, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled in United States v. Kozminski (1988) that involuntary servitude required physical or legal coercion and that extending this statute to psychological coercion alone would criminalize ordinary religious relationships, such as volunteering to put chairs back after a church bake sale (Introvigne 2026c). Congress, however, amended the law through the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000 (2000), adding psychological means as a basis of forced labor charges. Since then, psychological coercion arguments and training, largely based on Hassan’s “deprogramming lite” BITE model, have been found in FBI and Department of Justice documents.
For reference, Steven Hassan’s BITE model is built upon his mentor Margaret Singer’s brainwashing thesis, which was formally ruled as inadmissible after a review of hundreds of academic documents in the United States v. Fishman (1990) (The European Court of Human Rights also similarly ruled against the Russian government’s claims of brainwashing in Jehovah’s Witnesses of Moscow and Others v. Russia (2010)). BITE stands for “Behavior,” “Information,” “Thought,” and “Emotional control,” and applies indicators for each category that are so broad they can be applied to any group, religious or not (Introvigne 2026c). Hassan’s (2020) dissertation on the topic set out to prove the theory, but as external observers like Italian NRM and legal scholar Massimo Introvigne point out, it falls prey to self-selection bias from ex-member sampling, similar to Feliciano’s thesis (Introvigne 2026c; Feliciano 2023).
The legal precedent allows for a major challenge to religious freedom, which is now structural (Introvigne 2026a, 2026b). Through trafficking law and the OneTaste case ruling, any spiritual or religious group can now be accused of psychological coercion and manipulation by prosecutorial proof of intense commitment, volunteer labor, or deference to leadership. This means, in function and in practice, that every religion is vulnerable—not just high-tension groups. But, as is almost always the case, unpopular minority groups accused of being “cults” (typically through a function of normativity regulation) are far more frequently targeted. This is even though studies have shown that actual sexual abuse is far more statistically likely in mainline religions than in new religious movements (Å orytÄ— 2026, p. 73; Shupe 1995, 1998, 2000, 2007).
4.4. The United Kingdom
Under Section 76 of the UK’s Serious Crime Act (2015) abuse expanded beyond its traditional legal framework to recognize patterns of coercive control. For prosecution, the following must be present: repeated, continuous patterns of psychological abuse, coercion that occurs in an interpersonal dynamic, and evidence that the victim faces impairment in their daily life. This must be reasonably alarming behavior for a reasonable person (Serious Crime Act 2015).
Subsection 3 of the Serious Crime Act (2015) exempts parental authority if the child is under the age of 16. In doing so, parental authority is recognized to have a degree of control that supports normative parenting. This functions to prevent normative parenting from criminalization (Serious Crime Act 2015). This exemption of parental control from criminalization resembles the legal defenses that deprogrammers like Ted Patrick used historically to support their activities (Parker 2021, p. 196). This could be considered a subtle piece of evidence of the influence of anti-cult and cult awareness rhetoric and argumentation manifesting in UK law.
Although not entirely related to the Serious Crime Act (2015), there is some precedent of the UK government formally supporting the idea of “coercive control” attribution to groups rather than just individuals. At the University of Salford, a master’s degree program is available to students in “Coercive Control” (also available as a postgraduate diploma and certificate). Drs. Linda and Rod Dubrow-Marshall, the latter being a board member of the International Cultic Studies Association, created and primarily administer the program. Salford is a public university, which receives at least some funding from the UK government. Although this does not necessarily show that the UK government is in full support of studies on group-based coercive control, it is evidence that the government is growing accustomed to funding projects and programs on the idea.
4.5. Coercive Control Laws in the United States
The US federal government has no federal statutes against “coercive control” aside from the psychological coercion elements found within the Trafficking Victims Protection Act, but some states have enacted explicit laws against it like Hawaii and California. US courts can now use the legal precedent of coercive control to affect legal outcomes on childcare.
In 2020, the California legislature amended a section of its Family Code to include restrictions on coercive control (Garrett 2023). It amended a section dictating limitations on awarding custody of children to separating parents based on somewhat vague criteria. The new change considers “coercive control” to be any of the following: “Isolating the other party from friends, relatives, or other sources of support,” “Depriving the other party of basic necessities,” “Controlling, regulating, or monitoring the other party’s movements, communications, daily behavior, finances, economic resources, or access to services,” and “Compelling the other party by force, threat of force, or intimidation, including threats based on actual or suspected immigration status, to engage in conduct from which the other party has a right to abstain or to abstain from conduct in which the other party has a right to engage” (California Family Code 2025). Isolation, deprivation, and force are not necessarily concepts limited to the anti-cult sphere of thought, but through the written materials of some anti-cultists and some cultic studies scholars, “coercive control” seems to heavily resemble the ways that “cults” recruit and control members (see Hassan 2015). Although not in a NRM context, Hazani v. Hazani (2022) is one case in which California coercive control law was used to decide who retained custody of the children in a Jewish divorce (see Silverberg 2025; California Family Code 2025).
The state legislature of Hawaii passed a comparable bill in 2020 about coercive control. It defines “coercive control” similarly to the 2020 California law. It defines it as “a pattern of threatening, humiliating, or intimidating actions, which may include assaults, or other abuse that is used to harm, punish, or frighten an individual” (Hawaii Revised Statutes 2025). It is a “pattern of behavior that seeks to take away the individual’s liberty or freedom and strip away the individual’s sense of self, including bodily integrity and human rights” and is “designed to make an individual dependent by isolating them from support, exploiting them, depriving them of independence, and regulating their everyday behavior” (Hawaii Revised Statutes 2025). The law’s insistence that coercive control is an attempt to “take away the individual’s liberty or freedom” or their “sense of self” resembles exit counselor Steven Hassan’s understanding of “cultic” behavior (Hassan 2015). NRM scholars have noted that anti-cult sentiments are not necessarily anti-religious sentiments (Parker 2021), so although these and other coercive control laws are not targeting religion specifically, they do not have to be in order to be influenced by anti-cult theory.
5. Discussion
While the First Amendment to the US Constitution allows for the freedom of exercise when it comes to religious belief, the coercive control legal precedent that is emerging in US states and internationally creates an opportunity for anti-cultism to use parens patriae and the biopolitical function of the state to interrupt religious socialization and pick a winner in the religious market, much like what we can see in the Japanese case. While this is not happening en masse across the country yet, these laws may allow a systematic and structural way to legalize deprogramming through moral appeals made to protect children, as it has in the human trafficking precedent (the OneTaste case). As scholars who study new religious movements and believe in religious freedom, we would be remiss not to point this out. Though we do not reject the legal precedent of coercive control en toto, we urge lawmakers to further specify coercive control definitions as dyadic to eliminate potential ambiguity. A stronger measure would isolate the abusive criminal mechanics without drifting into discussions of religion operating as a form of abusive control (for more, see Goodwin 2020).
In a premier anti-cult journal International Journal of Coercion, Abuse, and Manipulation, Lagorse (2026) writes the following passage:
“In conclusion, I argue that cultic groups are a specific context in which women are subject to male authority, and using the term “patriarchal communities” to describe them is possible. In this context, coercive control theory seems relevant for understanding women’s experiences within cultic groups. First, it appears to be a context that resembles an intimate partner violence context, but what makes it different is that control comes from both the leader and the other members of the group”.
(Lagorse 2026, p. 99)
Lagorse, among others, make a mistake that we should be wary of codifying into legality. The shift from intimate partner violence frameworks from individual accountability to group accountability (like a RICO criminal conspiracy, a charge with an infamous history in NRM studies—see Singer and Ofshe’s lawsuit of the American Psychological Association, American Sociological Association, and roughly two dozen new religious movement scholars dismissed in 1993 (Singer v. American Psychological Association (1993)) is exactly the type of legal slippage that scholars should reject. The dynamics are completely different (Introvigne 2026a, 2026b). If fully implemented and codified, coercive control legislation derived from this epistemology can be used to fully criminalize whole religious groups. Where does the carceralization process of the state end (Foucault 1978, 1995)? Indeed, many feminist scholars ask as much.5 This would be a flagrant abuse of legal power and potentially lead to a criminalization of non-normative religious practice en toto, flying in the face of the First Amendment and providing the legal precedent for state-led deprogramming.
Building upon a carceral feminist epistemology found in Lamboley et al. (2022) that automatically assumes that all high-tension religious groups are patriarchal in organizational practice (which is an unfounded assumption), the extension of the IPV literature into coercive control embeds a conceptual slippage from individual accountability to group accountability. While the authors pay lip service to criticism of this slippage and danger to religious freedom largely coming from sociologists of religion like Eileen Barker and James T. Richardson (Lamboley et al. 2022, p. 38), they press forward with the well-known anti-cult perspective of sociologist Janja Lalich. This lack of critical interrogation when incorporating “cults” into the coercive control literature is also seen quite readily in Duron et al. (2021), who unquestioningly add “cults” to the list of coercive control contexts alongside human trafficking, intimate partner violence, and child and elder abuse.
Rather than assuming a “high-control” environment with the assumption of an omnipotent and abusive leader, criminological theories should acknowledge the literature indicating that “high-control” religious settings are often collaborative, agential, and self-selecting (Richardson 2021; Prophet 2016). A reliance on “ex-member accounts” has a known effect on research findings—mainly that it sensationalizes and dramatizes accounts of trauma and has response bias (for example, see Bromley et al. (1979) and Introvigne (2026c)). This is the same issue that fueled the “Cult Wars” of the 1970s and 1980s—reliance on ex-member accounts to support claims of brainwashing to encourage deprogramming (as seen in Hassan’s BITE model (Hassan 2020) and Feliciano’s thesis (Feliciano 2023)). The only difference is now anti-cultism is gaining a legitimate foothold for establishing religious regulation policy (deprogramming) through FBI training and law that protects battered and trafficked women and abused children (Introvigne 2026b).
6. Conclusions
Our goal is not to recreate the Cult Wars of the 1970s and 1980s. We acknowledge the adage of NRM scholarship: “some groups are criminal some of the time.” We are concerned, then, about the increase in scholars and lawmakers using coercive control frameworks to understand group settings. In 2026, the International Cultic Studies Association’s annual conference hosted at least 28 items on its schedule relating to coercive control, almost all of which used it to understand group dynamics. In approximately the last five years, numerous US states have passed civil and criminal legislation against “coercive control,” which is at least partially founded on anti-cult theory.
We are concerned about the potential for use of coercive control legislation to discriminate against new religious movements and, for lack of a better term, use the state as an anti-cult weapon, such as what we see in the OneTaste case. In Japan, for example, the state ordered the dissolution of the Unification Church, a notorious new religious movement, after a court found the NRM guilty of fraud (Duval 2026; Kuhn 2026). We suspect that, despite the Unification Church being particularly controversial in Japan after the assassination of former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, this is not the end. Coercive control law and its usage as a framework for understanding group dynamics rather than dyadic ones may be used in the near future against other high-tension religions—harmful or not.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, M.B. and S.F.; formal analysis, M.B.,L.P. and S.F.; investigation, M.B.,L.P. and S.F.; writing—original draft preparation, M.B.,L.P. and S.F.; writing—review and editing, M.B. and S.F.; supervision, S.F.; project administration, S.F.; funding acquisition, S.F. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.