Showing posts with label medical fraud. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medical fraud. Show all posts

Mar 14, 2018

Police bust sect, acolytes enslaved (3)


Forced to donate money, in Marche, Emilia Romagna

14 March 2018

(ANSA) - Rome, March 14 - Italian police on Wednesday busted a 'macrobiotic' sect that allegedly enslaved acolytes and forced them to donate money.

The alleged sect operated in Emilia Romagna and Marche, police said.

The members were allegedly enslaved, police said, through stringent dietary restrictions and the prevention of all contact with the outside world.

One of the so-called acolytes of the macrobiotic sect lost so much weight that she ended up wighing only 35 kg, police said.

Five people were placed under investigation.

The sect's guru, Mario Pianesi, told his followers "drugs don't work, they only get rid of symptoms, medicine kills, doctors are killers", members of the sect told police.

The man managed to persuade sick sect members to abandon traditional medicine and follow his macrobiotic diet to allegedly solve their physical and psychological problems, police said.

http://www.ansa.it/english/news/general_news/2018/03/14/police-bust-sect-acolytes-enslaved-3_05a893a2-d7b1-44f0-81da-ea44c650428b.html

Jan 30, 2018

The woman who fooled the world

The Woman Who Fooled the World, Beau Donelly and Nick Toscano, Scribe, paperback, 336 pages.
Simon Caterson on a book that shines a light on the shadows of Belle Gibson, the Australian hoaxer who shot to global fame with claims she had beaten terminal cancer without any medical intervention.

Simon Caterson
independent
January 7 2018

Non-fiction: The Woman Who Fooled the World, Beau Donelly and Nick Toscano, Scribe, paperback, 336 pages.

There can be few Australians detested more bitterly and in as many countries as Belle Gibson. The Melbourne-based 29-year-old fake-cancer sufferer and charity fraudster enjoyed a meteoric rise to international fame and fortune as a "wellness" guru who preached against the toxicity of modern life.

Gibson's spectacular ascent was followed by an equally rapid fall into infamy after her hurtful and financially damaging scams were exposed in 2015. She and her former publisher have since been fined heavily under Australian consumer protection laws, with her misconduct excoriated from the bench of the Federal Court. To date, she has yet to face criminal charges.

The Woman Who Fooled the World is a balanced and authoritative account of Gibson's career. Apart from the light it sheds on the substantial areas of shade in Gibson's life and character, the book is essential reading for anyone seeking an understanding of how so many people could have fallen for her pernicious lies.

Co-authors Beau Donelly and Nick Toscano are award-winning investigative journalists whose reporting on this complex and multifaceted story for The Age newspaper in Melbourne played a pivotal role in exposing the scandal.

Gibson didn't just lie big time and use the leverage the lies gave her to misappropriate a large amount of donation money. Also unpardonable was the false hope she gave to the real-life cancer sufferers and their loved ones persuaded by Gibson that this cruel disease could be treated effectively without medical intervention.

No breakthrough in medicine is longed for more than a cure for cancer, yet a cure remains elusive. As one senior neuro-oncologist quoted in the book observes in relation to brain cancer: "People often refuse to accept that there is no answer".

Cancer sufferers can thus be highly susceptible to purported remedies that have no clinical standing. The authors note in passing that the late Steve Jobs, the mercurial head of Apple who died from pancreatic cancer in 2011, chose to delay conventional medical treatment in favour of alternative therapies. It was a decision Jobs told his biographer he later regretted.

As historian Philippa Martyr demonstrates in Paradise of Quacks, false health claims of one kind or another are nothing new in Australia. In the rogue's gallery of contemporary health hoaxers, Gibson takes her place alongside such notorious Australian con artists as Peter Foster, who promoted dodgy weight-loss schemes at home and in the UK, where notoriously he became associated in property dealings with Cherie Blair, the wife of former prime minister Tony.

Belief in quackery begins with the charm and guile of the quack. Like many world-class liars, Gibson began practising to deceive at an early age while growing up in the Brisbane suburb of Wynnum.

As the authors recount: "Those who knew her describe a melodramatic girl with a tendency to imitate others, who was prone to lying. She'd say things about her life and about her family that seemed totally unbelievable. Over the years, she told a number of people that she was in a witness-protection programme. One classmate recalls Gibson claiming she was a test-tube baby."

Adapting to audience feedback and refining her shtick, Gibson's lies coalesced around imaginary medical problems. A sizable number of the people who knew Gibson personally did not believe the yarns she spun about overcoming severe illness.

"On the internet, though, something different was starting to happen. In a chat room about rock band The Flaming Lips, her stories of astonishing medical miracles were beginning to be believed. There were some doubters, but also huge outpourings of sympathy and support. Here, Gibson's biggest, most prolific, and most dangerous lie was born."

Gibson's claim to have tamed terminal brain cancer through the "self-empowerment" of certain dietary practices fell on fertile ground when propagated via social media. The foundational falsehood on which Gibson built a reputation as a plausible wellness warrior was lent plausibility by her carefully crafted presence on Instagram, attracting hundreds of thousands of followers.

Later came a bestselling smartphone app that received a major award from Apple, which in turn was joined by a slickly presented recipe book published by Penguin. The Belle Gibson show thus received substantial backing from two highly respected global brands. "Gibson, for a while, was untouchable", the authors note. Many people - including celebrities, prominent business people and other influential figures - associated themselves enthusiastically with Gibson. In our culture nothing, it seems, succeeds like success.

And 2014 was the champagne year for Belle. With cash pouring in from sales of the app and book, Gibson embraced the lifestyle of the rich and famous, buying a luxury SUV to complement her lavishly furnished upmarket apartment in the posh Melbourne bayside suburb of Brighton. She hired a personal trainer and had her teeth fixed.

The vast "wellness" industry had warmly embraced Gibson, and for a while it seemed nothing could stop her from becoming her own global brand. Only after scrutiny from serious journalists such as Donelly and Toscano, among other principled sceptics, was Gibson exposed as a con artist.

One former friend spoke to the authors of a sense of utter betrayal, no doubt giving voice to the feelings of many others similarly duped: "I admired her and loved her. Now I feel like an idiot."

Simon Caterson is a Melbourne-based writer and author of Hoax Nation: Australian Fakes and Frauds

Indo Review

May 31, 2017

Doctor found guilty over referrals

Northern Star
May 31, 2017
Cathy Adams

A doctor who sent a patient off for new age healing treatments such as "esoteric lung massage" has been found guilty of unsatisfactory professional conduct.

The patient, a 55-year-old Ballina woman with a persistent cough, consulted thoracic physician Samuel Kim in Goonellabah in 2010.

The Professional Standards Board found that Dr Kim inappropriately referred the patient to esoteric practitioners from the controversial Universal Medicine spiritual healing group, of which he was a member.

During the course of her two-year treatment under Dr Kim, the patient was sent to Universal Medicine for "treatments" such as "chemo washing" through "chakra puncture" and "esoteric lung massage".

The patient made a complaint to the Health Care Complaints Commission, claiming she was not only misdiagnosed but also told she had to go on the lung transplant list. She was also prescribed hormone replacement therapy and put on vitamin B injections.

The HCCC took the complaint before the Professional Standards Committee.

The complaint was proven, with the exception of the innappropriate administration of B12 injections.

Dr Kim accepted his conduct was significantly below the standard to be reasonably expected of a practitioner with his level of training or experience.

He also accepted that his conduct was improper and unethical.

The Committee noted there was no complaint made about Dr Kim's approach to the conventional medical treatment of the patient's lung disease, and was not critical of Dr Kim's interest or training in Universal Medicine, but was critical of his referrals to Universal Medicine practitioners.

The Committee found Dr Kim had not adequately explained the difference between conventional and complementary medicine, stating "every effort must be made by a medical practitioner to make those boundaries clear and ensure that the patient understands the nature of any treatment that is recommended".

In oral evidence, Dr Kim acknowledged he was an advocate for and supporter of Universal Medicine principles.

MORE

https://www.northernstar.com.au/news/doctor-found-guilty-over-referrals/3184226/

May 30, 2017

Universal Medicine affiliated doctor reprimanded

Chris Dobney
Echo Net Daily
May 30, 2017

A Goonellabah lung specialist and Queensland University lecturer, Dr Samuel Tae-Kyu Kim, has been reprimanded by the Medical Council of New South Wales Professional Standards Committee following a complaint by a patient to the Health Care Complaints Commission.

The complainant, referred to in the inquiry as ‘Patient A’, first consulted Dr Kim in October 2010 for chronic cough, which was ultimately diagnosed as ‘hypersensitivity pneumonitis’.


Esoteric therapies


Dr Kim recommended to Patient A various esoteric therapies offered by Universal Medicine, including to ‘esoteric lung massage’ offered by his wife and fellow UM student, Jasna Jugovic.

She was also referred to compounding chemist Michael Serafin for ‘bioidentical hormone replacement therapy’ as well as to another UM associated practitioner, Neil Ringe, for ‘chakra puncture’ therapy.

Dr Kim also recommended the patient contact UM leader Serge Benhayon for a consultation.

In November 2012, he emailed Patient A “…I also feel you should see Serge Benhayon one day sooner than later to help you – as your physical medicine is going well otherwise…..”

Dr Kim admitted to the Committee that, ‘At the time that I sent the email to Patient A I thought that I was clear that Mr Benhayon was not offering physical medical treatment. Mr Benhayon offers “spiritual healing” ….

‘I acknowledge that I did not make sufficiently clear to Patient A the distinction between the conventional medicine I was providing as her thoracic physician and the complementary therapies I recommended she pursue with Mr Ringe, Ms Jugovic, Mr Serafin and Mr Benhayon.’


Significantly below standard


The Committee determined that Dr Kim’s conduct was ‘significantly below the standard reasonably expected of a practitioner with his level of training and experience.’

They determined he ‘inappropriately recommended and prescribed bioidentical HRT for Patient A, when this was outside the scope of his expertise and done without appropriate referral.’

He was also reprimanded for recommending esoteric lung massage and chakra puncture, ‘knowing there was insufficient evidence for their efficacy as treatments for Patient A’s lung condition.’

Dr Kim stated that chakra puncture is an ‘internationally recognised therapy’, although Universal Medicine is the only group which practices and teaches chakra puncture.

He also told the Committee that he had recommended chakra puncture for persistent chest pain, but without first referring Patient A to a Pain Clinic. He said he didn’t have a strong relationship with the local Pain Clinic and didn’t think Patient A had the kind of pain which was appropriate for referral to a Pain Clinic. Dr Kim said that with hindsight he ‘could have done better’.


UM connection


Dr Kim told the Committee that since 2005 he has been a student of Universal Medicine and had undertaken a number of Universal Medicine courses. He pays an annual fee to be a member of Universal Medicine’s Esoteric Practitioners Association and receives newsletters from, and attends conferences of, the Association.

He has written an article which is on the Universal Medicine website and also a letter to the Courier Mail newspaper around September 2012 defending Universal Medicine.

Dr Kim leases premises from Universal Medicine and his professional letterhead states that the Blue Hills Lung Clinic is located in the Universal Medicine Clinic. In oral evidence he acknowledged he was an advocate for and supporter of Universal Medicine principles.

Dr Kim admitted he did not explain any interconnections between himself and Universal Medicine practitioners Neil Ringe, Serge Benhayon and Michael Serafin, but asserted he has no ‘interconnections’ with these practitioners other than they are all members of Universal Medicine and the Esoteric Practitioners Association.

He acknowledged that he has trained in Universal Medicine with Mr Ringe and Mr Serafin and some of his patients have also consulted Mr Ringe, Mr Benhayon and Mr Serafin.

Dr Kim admitted that he did not disclose his connection to Ms Jugovic to whom he is now married.

The Committee stated that as the esoteric treatments offered to Patient A were ‘not treatments generally regarded as part of the repertoire of respiratory medicine and they are not recognised by Medicare… full disclosure is essential to allow a patient to make an informed and appropriate choice.’


19th century attitude


The Committee heard evidence from Dr Yates, a consultant thoracic physician and Senior Staff Specialist at St Vincent Hospital in Sydney.

She said UM ‘affects an attitude which conventional medicine abandoned in the 19th century and this heightens the need to clearly distinguish for patients the difference between conventional medicine and Universal Medicine. Particularly as it is unclear, given it is a relatively new organisation, how Universal Medicine’s training programs are accredited.’

The Committee accepted her evidence as to the need for doctors to exercise caution and openly disclose personal connections and personal beliefs about unproven medical treatments, when referring patients to other practitioners, especially when the referral is for treatments which are not generally accepted evidence-based treatments.


Ruling

The Committee ruled that, ‘prior to recommending or referring a patient for complementary therapies or treatment, [Dr Kim] must obtain a written opinion from a specialist thoracic physician who has been approved by the Council. [Dr Kim] must provide a copy of the patient’s medical records to the thoracic physician for review and must discuss the patient’s diagnosis, current condition, prognosis and the nature and purpose of the proposed complementary therapies or treatment.’

It also required that, ‘at the time of recommending or referring a patient for complementary therapy or treatment, [Dr Kim] must:

explain to the patient the distinction between conventional therapies or treatment and the complementary therapies or treatment being discussed.
inform the patient of any professional or personal connection the practitioner has with person(s) the patient is being recommended or referred to.’
Dr Kim has the right to seek a review by the Medical Council of NSW of the Committee’s order to impose conditions on his registration.

MORE

https://www.echo.net.au/2017/05/universal-medicine-affiliated-doctor-reprimanded/

Doctor rebuked over 'spiritual healing' group touting 'esoteric breast massage'

Authorities say Samuel Tae-Kyu Kim failed to disclose his involvement in Universal Medicine when inappropriately referring a patient to devotees of group

Joshua Robertson
The Guardian
May 30, 2017


A doctor and university lecturer who advocates for a controversial “spiritual healing” group touting unproven treatments including “esoteric breast massage” has been given a scathing reprimand by medical authorities.

The respiratory physician Samuel Tae-Kyu Kim failed to disclose his involvement in Universal Medicine when inappropriately referring a patient to other devotees of the group, including its founder, a former bankrupt tennis coach with no medical qualifications.

Kim, 46, who practises at a premises owned by the group at Lismore and a private medical centre in Brisbane, told the professional standards committee of the Medical Council of New South Wales that he first suspected the patient’s complaint was part of a “conspiracy” to discredit Universal Medicine as a cult.

But the committee found this month he made “significant ethical errors and failings in respect of proper professional standards” in treating the woman for more than two years for a chronic cough.

Kim, also an unpaid senior lecturer at the University of Queensland medical school, told the woman that “deep-seated grief is a major driving factor in lung disease”.

The committee heard that Kim inappropriately prescribed an unconventional “bioidentical” hormone replacement therapy provided by Michael Serafin, a compound pharmacist and Universal Medicine participant, in what the physician admitted was an area “beyond the scope” of his medical expertise.

NSW health authorities investigated Serafin last year over his manufacture of a cocktail of injectable vitamins for use in a Sydney “hangover” clinic that was shut down when a client was hospitalised after an intravenous infusion.

Serafin is now forbidden by the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency from making or supplying the so-called “Myer’s Cocktail” hangover mixture or products containing ketamine.

The committee noted Kim’s “competence in the practice of conventional respiratory medicine is at odds with an apparent casual acceptance of unproven treatments”.

This was “even to the extent of accepting, for [the patient] an HRT treatment ‘prescribed’ by a non-medically trained pharmacist, without inquiring into the actual nature or composition of that treatment”, it said.

Kim did not make clear to the patient that he had trained in Universal Medicine with Serafin and Neil Ringe, who performed “chakra puncture”, another unproven Universal Medicine treatment, on the woman.

Kim referred the woman to his partner, now wife, and fellow Universal Medicine devotee, Jasna Jugovic, for a $70 “esoteric lung massage”, without disclosing their relationship or that there was no scientific evidence the treatment worked.

He also urged the patient to see the Universal Medicine founder, Serge Benhayon.

Kim told the committee that Benhayon “offers ‘spiritual healing’ which, to my observation, can be used to complement conventional medicine, much in the same way many people find benefit from meditation or religion when they suffer from chronic illness”.

But Kim admitted he “did not make sufficiently clear to [the patient] the distinction between the conventional medicine I was providing as her thoracic physician and the complementary therapies I recommended she pursue with Mr Ringe, Ms Jugovic, Dr Serafin and Mr Benhayon”.

Universal Medicine has previously come under fire from medical experts, including professor John Dwyer, the president of the Friends of Science in Medicine.

Dwyer told a 2014 state parliamentary inquiry into false and misleading health practices: “There is no doubt whatsoever in my mind that 99.9% of doctors would be horrified to think that [Universal Medicine-linked doctors] would place patients in the hands of these people ... Could it be that these doctors actually believe?”

Dwyer said Universal Medicine subjected patients to “a whole series of nonsense therapeutic approaches”, including “esoteric breast massage”.

“They claim they can massage your back and actually massage your lungs if you have lung conditions; the practitioners say they have the power to talk to a woman’s ovaries and learn about that; and they explain that all illnesses are due to past misdeeds in previous incarnations of your life.”

The inquiry found there was little evidence of actual harm but “concerns were raised that patients may forgo seeking proper medical advice and care”.

Two patients undergoing Universal Medicine therapies were independently diagnosed with cancer and bronchiectasis and needed medical intervention to be properly treated, it said.

Kim did not refer his patient for esoteric breast massage. But on a website he has praised it as “a great opportunity for women to influence their own health and wellbeing and to potentially alter the current trajectory of serious disease”.

“In addition to medical care, these beautiful women choose nurturing ways of preventing ‘breast cysts’, ‘painful lumps’ or ‘coldness’ in parts of their breasts,” Kim says.

A respiratory medicine expert called by the committee, Deborah Yates, said Universal Medicine affected an attitude towards the origin of illness “which conventional medicine abandoned in the 19th century”.

This “heightens the need to clearly distinguish for patients the difference between conventional medicine and Universal Medicine”, Yates said.

The committee found Kim’s referrals to fellow Universal Medicine devotees “lie at the heart of his unsatisfactory professional conduct” and it remained “concerned that Dr Kim does not adequately recognise his own bias in relation to Universal Medicine practices”.

It ordered he seek the approval of a second specialist before referring patients to complementary therapists, and clearly explain the difference from conventional medicine and any personal or professional links with them.

Kim must also submit to regular supervision and an audit of his medical practice by the Medical Council of NSW.

He has the right to seek a review of the ruling with the council and to appeal it in the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

MORE

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/may/31/doctor-rebuked-over-spiritual-healing-group-touting-esoteric-breast-massage

Nov 2, 2016

Here's Why Authorities Want to Stop the Sale of Jim Humble's Miracle Cure

NOVEMBER 1, 2016
BY CRAIG MALISOW
Houston Press

On the morning of May 12, 22-year-old Jennifer Hollis bought the gun she would use to kill herself later that day.

According to a friend who spoke with a salesperson at the Academy Sports off I-10, Hollis, a petite, black-haired woman with a beauty mark just above her left eyebrow, was perfectly composed. She asked a lot of questions about brands, calibers, uses. She left the store with the gun and a box of copper-jacket bullets.

At the doctor’s office where the University of Houston student worked as an assistant, she seemed fine as well, except for a crying jag when a coworker showed off her engagement ring. Later, investigators would determine that she spent three minutes online researching information about suicide notes. No one noticed anything out of the ordinary when she left the clinic, near Rice University, sometime after 3 p.m.
In the 18 days before her body was found in her silver RAV4 on the roof of a parking garage off West Loop South, friends and family led a frantic search. Before Hollis disappeared, she had experienced mood swings, scattered thoughts, difficulty concentrating. She had attributed this to a form of “chronic Lyme disease,” a condition unsupported by mainstream medicine.

What friends didn’t know, what slowly trickled out during those 18 days, was that Hollis had been treating her condition by drinking, and taking enemas with, a bleach solution marketed as a cure-all by an organization calling itself Genesis II Church of Health and Healing.

Some friends now say that she had been ingesting a product called Miracle Mineral Solution, which was actually sodium chlorite. When mixed with an activating agent, like citric acid, it becomes chlorine dioxide, often used to purify industrial water systems and bleach textiles and wood pulp.

Here's Why Authorities Want to Stop the Sale of Jim Humble's Miracle Cure
Troy Fields
Six days before Hollis shot herself in the head, the Harris County Attorney’s Office had sought an injunction (as of October still pending) against a 45-year-old Angleton, Texas, air-conditioner repairman and firearms dealer who calls himself a “bishop” of Genesis II, and who hawks the miracle solution in hotel conference rooms. Attendees of these sales pitches, marketed as “sacramental training classes,” were told to bring a $500 cash donation in an envelope.

The Harris County Attorney’s Office called MMS dangerous, citing an FDA warning that ingesting high dosages of the bleach can cause nausea, vomiting, diarrhea and severe dehydration.
“Consumers who have MMS should stop using it immediately and throw it away,” the agency recommended in 2010.

While authorities have been able to go after domestic merchants of MMS — a distributor in Washington state was sentenced to 51 months in federal prison in 2015 — the head of the Genesis II Church lived until recently in a walled compound in the Dominican Republic, beyond the reach of U.S. law enforcement.

That leader, Jim Humble, is an 83-year-old ex-Scientologist and gold prospector who claims to have stumbled upon the miracle cure while on a South American expedition in 1996. He also claims to be a member of an ancient alien race.

In YouTube videos Hollis posted in the months before her death, she doesn’t mention the church. What the videos show instead is a woman who had been experiencing severe emotional distress and who, although clearly intelligent, was nevertheless duped into dousing her insides with bleach.

For Hollis, the “mineral solution” peddled by Genesis II was not a miracle cure. And while state and federal authorities around the country try to stop the sale of MMS, its chief propagandist continues to make videos touting its wonders, which feeds into the views of anti-mainstream medicine, anti-vaccination conspiracy theorists who not only drink it themselves, but force it on their children.

*****
The Harris County Attorney’s Office is seeking an injunction against Shane Hawkins, an “archbishop” of the Genesis II Church.
The Harris County Attorney’s Office is seeking an injunction against Shane Hawkins, an “archbishop” of the Genesis II Church.
Screenshot, www.giveforward.com/fundraiser/gy21

A religious awakening can occur in the most unexpected of places. In April 2016, one was to occur at a Ramada Inn near a Houston airport.

The last weekend in April was supposed to have been a sacramental class in which Genesis II Church Reverend Shane Hawkins would teach, for a fee, the “chemistry of chlorine dioxide solution.” The fee included a one-year church membership, a “Reverend Certificate,” the ability to “restore health from 95% of the diseases of mankind,” plus drinks and snacks.

Unfortunately for Hawkins, the Ramada Houston Intercontinental Airport East, in Humble, canceled the engagement, which Hawkins’s website chalked up to religious persecution. Although Genesis II founder Jim Humble calls his church “non-religious,” his organization proudly wears its persecution on its sleeve, and revels in religious titles and terminology.

When the Houston Press asked Hawkins about how the Harris County Attorney was trying to prohibit sales of MMS, Hawkins said, “You mean trying to violate my religious freedoms? That’s all I’m going to say about it. We don’t do interviews — the Archbishop has told us not to do interviews with the press because you guys have always twisted our words and made us look in a negative light, no matter what we say.”

Hawkins’s mandated denial seems fitting for a man who has seemingly felt a need to be led by a strong voice of authority.

Prior to establishing “Chapter 119” of the Genesis II Church, Hawkins was a member of a polygamous cult called the House of Yahweh. The group was founded in a West Texas trailer park by an ex-Abilene police officer named Bill Hawkins, who changed his first name to Yisrayl, and ordered his followers to change their surnames to Hawkins. (As one of Yisrayl Hawkins’s brothers, who was not part of the cult, told Texas Monthly in 1997: “He ain’t got both oars in the water, if you know what I mean.”) Hence, Louisiana-born Shane Broussard became Shane Hawkins.

Like other House of Yahweh followers, who dwelt in tenements on their leader’s 44-acre property, Hawkins lived a meager lifestyle. In his 2005 bankruptcy filing, Hawkins claimed to support his wife and four kids, all under 13 years old, while making just over $1,000 a month, with $108 monthly “contributions” to the House of Yahweh. His truck had been repossessed and he had no phone service.

Six years later, Hawkins’s gut had ballooned, but not his wallet. Showing that morbid obesity is not within the 95 percent of conditions cured by the Miracle Mineral Solution, Hawkins weighed 492 pounds and was begging online for enough money to pay for a juicer and $300 a month for vegetables.

He posted pics of himself standing, and reclining, in nothing but a disturbingly skimpy pair of boxers. He claimed that donations were tax-deductible because he was a reverend in the Genesis II Church.

Hawkins’s church website states, “We are unique because we were formed to serve mankind. We are non-religious in nature because we serve mankind, as opposed to worshiping a deity.” Members are “exempt” from “vaccinations, medications, X-rays, scans, mandatory voting, and health insurance mandated by a human government or authority.”

The church’s entire existence is based on the Miracle Mineral Supplement, sold by third-party merchants and distributed for free by church members in remote African and Haitian villages, among other places. Church videos show impoverished families lining up to drink bleach, and Genesis II claims to have proof that the Red Cross has used it to treat malaria in Uganda.

According to the church’s website, all one needs to do to become a “consecrated” bishop or health minister — and thus qualify to teach others how to use MMS — is attend a seminar, usually held in the Dominican Republic or Puerto Vallarta. Over the years, the cost of these five-day seminars has dipped from $1,000 to $650 per person. (A 2012 Puerto Vallarta seminar featured Kerri Rivera, who claims to have “cured” hundreds of autistic children via chlorine dioxide, and whose book, Healing the Symptoms Known as Autism, is a bible of quackery. Chlorine dioxide, unfortunately, cannot cure typos: Rivera is called “Riviera” in the seminar’s ad copy, which also touts “Jet Ski’s.”)

Ostensibly, the seminars help drill into the heads of bishops that the Miracle Mineral Solution is not bleach. That’s just what the government wants sheeple to believe. As one church disclaimer clarifies, “MMS is not bleach, but is a bleaching compound and can be used to bleach things.” The disclaimer also reminds people that “even simple water, if you drink too much at one time, WILL KILL YOU.”

The church’s membership numbers and financials are fuzzy. As of August 2016, the church claims to have trained 1,750 health ministers in more than 100 countries, which doesn’t include lay members. It costs $35 to join the church, and $20 a year thereafter, but, as at many county fairs and chain diners, kids under 12 are half-price.

In a somewhat confusing structure, possibly meant to avoid liability, church officials try to keep at arm’s length from direct sales of MMS, referring consumers to “approved” suppliers in the United States and elsewhere. The church’s website lists suppliers throughout South America, Canada, Africa, the Netherlands and New Zealand. In turn, these suppliers tend to couch sales as “donations,” and some won’t overtly state that you’re actually supposed to drink MMS, preferring instead to link to “sacramental instructions” posted on other sites. It’s an extremely confusing, tangled mess.

Some sellers go to even greater lengths to hide their sales: Louis Smith, a Washington state seller of MMS convicted by federal authorities in 2015, created fake “water purification” businesses “in order to obtain sodium chlorite and ship his MMS without being detected by” the FDA or customs officials, according to the U.S. Department of Justice.

On average, the components of MMS — twin bottles of sodium chlorite and hydrochloric acid that are mixed together — cost $25. But the church directly sells Humble’s books and videos.

For $55, the Press bought bottles of sodium chlorite, hydrochloric acid, dimethyl sulfite and calcium hypochlorite (“MMS2”) and a bag of capsules from a Genesis II chapter in Bradenton, Florida. The chapter’s site states, “We do not Sell any of our Sacraments, We only provide our Sacraments through DONATION [sic].” (Even though the items were individually wrapped, the odor of bleach was overwhelming, even a week later.)

However, MMS is available to anyone, not just church members. And it has become increasingly popular among anti-vaccination parents who claim their children are autistic, a condition they believe is caused by intestinal parasites called ropeworms. These beasties, they believe, are excreted after MMS enemas, often accompanied by streams of viscous “biofilm.”

In one church video, a woman — her body blacked out to protect her from religious persecution — describes the awesome progress MMS has had on her young son. She started off by dropping a small amount in the child’s bathwater before stepping things up.

“Once we put in the enemas, it was like night and day,” she says. “He started passing a lot of worms. Starting having a lot of biofilm-type stuff he’s passing. We’ve had several instances where he’s passed — I’m assuming it’s stool, but it was calcified, so it’s hard as a rock. You physically couldn’t cut it with a razor blade. I mean, it’s like a piece of rock coming out of him…Obviously, that wasn’t spaghetti from last week. That’s been in there a long time.”

It’s unclear what exactly these children are expelling, but it’s certainly not parasitic worms. Medical experts contacted by the Press suggest that it’s probably colon mucus and sloughed-off intestinal lining. It’s also unclear what kind of damage prolonged colonic injection of bleach can do to the insides of a child, let alone an adult, perhaps because no regulatory or research apparatus ever conceived of a home or workplace environment where bleach might accidentally shoot up someone’s rectum.

When used as directed, chlorine dioxide can be hazardous enough, according to the FDA. The EPA and OSHA also set extremely low limits for what’s considered safe exposure, while the Genesis II “protocols” call for levels that are thousands of times higher.

“In very low concentrations, chlorine dioxide can be used as a water purifier,” the Harris County Attorney’s Office states in its motion for injunction. “However, at the suggested doses, the chemical is toxic to humans.”

Citing the pending litigation, Assistant Harris County Attorney Rosemarie Donnelly declined to comment, other than to say: “We’re continuing to monitor the situation.”

Hawkins’s hand-scrawled response to the Harris County Attorney’s Office might make sense to him, but for the uninitiated, it’s puzzling. It begins, “Greetings Chris,” addressing Harris County District Clerk of Court Chris Daniel, whose name is automatically printed on all legal filings and who is not a party to the lawsuit.

It continues:

“i:man, Shane, accept for value your complaint…i:man, Shane, will settle the matter, on the private side, with any man or woman who verifies that I have done wrong, injury or harm to said man or woman.”
Church literature declares that, if taken properly, MMS could never hurt anyone. That’s something that medical experts, and people with common sense, dispute.

*****
Jim Humble claims to come from an ancient race of aliens.
Jim Humble claims to come from an ancient race of aliens.
Screenshot, Genesis II video

Depending on which source you believe, Jim Vern Humble was born in either Mobile, Alabama, in 1932, or the Andromeda Galaxy millions of years ago.

While the latter theory is more exciting, Humble seems to have walked it back after it was highlighted in stories by The Guardian and Forbes, and on many blogs. After these stories ran, the church seems to have gone on a scorched-earth campaign, scrubbing church-produced videos of the alien-origin story that were linked in the articles. Unfortunately for the church, it missed one. In an English-language interview on a German web series from 2015, Humble speaks of a collection of 55 planets ruled under the iron fist of a being named Manzanora. (Humble declined to comment for this story.)

Earth began as a prison planet and blew up on five occasions, but then, over millions of years, it became a sanctuary for well-meaning aliens, who recognized each other via implants that for some reason were embedded in their heads. They all wanted to get away from Manzanora, whose official title or rank remains unclear, primarily because Humble forgot.

“What do you call a guy who runs a planet?” Humble asked his puzzled hosts at one point. “They want to be the top guy. Higher than a president.”

In the video, which lasts an interminable 44 minutes, Humble seems dazed — he struggles to find the right words and goes off on tangents. He comes off as a doddering octogenarian making up a story as he goes along. (According to Humble’s son, James Humble-Sanchez, this forgetfulness isn’t even age-related. He says his father has always had short-term memory problems, and that his father used to say, “I’d ride my bike to school and walk home,” because he forgot how he got there.)

Critics call Genesis II a cult, which, if true, makes Humble the most uncharismatic cult leader of all time. He’s not Jim Jones; he’s your grandpa’s disoriented nursing home roommate. His voice is somehow subdued, shrill and monotone at the same time. He not only manages to make a story about aliens escaping to Earth boring, he apparently forgot that it clashes with a story he told a different interviewer that same year about how he first encountered alien beings in a giant hole in a California desert.

If an evil galactic overlord, ancient alien civilizations, prison planets and head implants sound familiar, that’s because it’s boilerplate Scientology, of which Humble was a member.

His name appears in a 1971 issue of a Scientology journal posted online that stated he was enrolled in a “Hubbard Standard Dianetics Course” in Orange County, California. His name also appears in mid-1980s newsletters distributed by a cabal of former members who left the church to start their own “independent” movement.

Back in the mid-1960s, Humble was living in southern California and working on an oil rig in the Santa Barbara Channel, according to his son, Humble-Sanchez. On shore leave, Humble met Theresa Lane, with whom he had two children. (Reached by phone, Lane said she didn’t remember much about Humble.)

After a divorce, Humble met his next wife while taking Scientology courses, Humble-Sanchez says. The two eventually started a business called Action Mining, whose claim to fame was the gold wave table. Designed by Humble, the table helped filter and recover gold and other minerals. The company also published a magazine called Popular Mining. (The couple later divorced; the ex-wife declined to comment for this story.)

By 1971, Humble was living in Los Angeles and compiling a 500-question test designed to identify a person’s nutritional deficiencies, which he sold to health food stores, Humble-Sanchez says. (Classified ads in the Los Angeles Times from that time show that Humble was seeking a licensed physician to help with the test.)

Humble-Sanchez said that he spoke to the Press only after getting the okay from his father, who he said no longer lives in the Dominican Republic. According to Humble-Sanchez, his father believes “even negative publicity is good publicity.” (He would not disclose Humble’s location, but a recent investigation by the Los Angeles ABC affiliate found Humble outside Guadalajara, Mexico.)

Throughout the 1980s, Humble also made a living conducting assays for mining ventures, while at the same time joining a burgeoning sect of ex-Scientologists who had grown disenchanted with what they felt was a corrupt leadership. The August 1984 issue of the group’s newsletter includes Humble’s account of his correspondence with Diana Hubbard Ryan, daughter of Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard, and a high-ranking member who was part of the organization’s elite “Sea Org” sanctum.

He wrote about what he saw as a pattern of organized religion: A church grows rich off its followers, who are exploited and suppressed until they break away and create their own movement. He claimed that people were turning away from Scientology because the leadership — “a few insane individuals that seem to work their way to the top” — was bent on manipulating their followers. They “understood the mind and how to use supression [sic] better than those in the past.”

Humble wrote, “How can anyone really have a monopoly on the truth? Those who support suppression obviously believe they deserve suppression.”

In a 1986 newsletter, Humble advertised his book, Science of Integrity, described as a work “with all the Scientologese terms removed and replaced with plain English.” He wrote that all proceeds would go toward something called the Religious Freedom Trust, which was allegedly raising money to help other defectors being sued by the church.

As another ex-wife told the Press, “He was very glad to get out of [Scientology], because it was all related to mind control. And he wanted freedom of mind. He did not want to be controlled.”

By 1987, Action Mining was holding seminars on “how to invest in [a] small gold mine,” according to a Los Angeles Times classified ad. The $250 fee for the seminar, which was to be held in Las Vegas, included a “free gold specimen” and a two-year subscription to Popular Mining.

All of these elements — Scientology’s pay-to-play structure and antipathy toward modern medicine; dubious seminars; and publishing — seemed to coalesce into what later became Genesis II.

According to Humble, he discovered chlorine dioxide’s healing powers while on an expedition in Guyana in 1996, when his crew came down with malaria. Far from their camp and medical supplies, they were dying and desperate. Humble quickly came up with the idea of using the stuff they had on hand to purify their drinking water, and four hours later, everyone was in tip-top shape, laughing about how close to death they were just a short while before.

In 2006, he wrote the first edition of The Miracle Mineral Supplement of the 21st Century, a treatise he believed was so groundbreaking and anti-authoritarian that he claimed in the foreword that the book’s copyright would be terminated upon his death, disappearance or detention “for more than 60 days during any 6 month period.”

Humble also cribbed from Scientology’s “Body Communication Process,” which, according to the Scientology Handbook, “is used when a person has been chronically out of communication with his body, such as after an illness or injury.” The process calls for the patient to lie down while the healer places his hands up and down’s the patient’s body, saying “Feel my hands” along the way.

In a Genesis II video, Humble demonstrates his version of this technique on a teenage boy named Bobby, who lies on a couch while Humble kneels beside him, wearing a battered fedora, ostensibly to show his ruggedness and sense of adventure. (Humble’s Plenty of Fish online dating profile — always a reassuring sign of leadership for an international bleach-drinking movement — is headlined “Indiana Jones looking for companion.”)

“You just touch all over the body,” Humble explains, moving his hands up and down, saying “Feel my fingers” and “With your mind, look under my fingers.”

An ex-wife told the Press that Humble was always into healthy eating and alternative medicine, that he sought longevity, perhaps even immortality. She edited his self-published book, Zero Resistance, about the importance of always finding beauty in your surroundings.

But he could also be stubborn: In the end, she claims, their marriage ended after only eight months because she liked chocolate pudding cups, and he didn’t want any of them in the house. It was, however, her house. So he left.

She says he found his subsequent two wives in Russia; those marriages were also short-lived. (The Press left voicemails at a number associated with one woman; another could not be located.)

Although the ex-wife thought Humble would have been “a great sci-fi writer,” he never spoke about aliens.
“He’s a dreamer,” she explains. “…He’s not a kook, or mean, [just] a little bit of an old fool.”

Humble’s son told the Press that he’s tried to talk his father out of marketing chlorine dioxide under the MMS name.

“It’s not a mineral, and it’s not a miracle, but it is a solution,” Humble-Sanchez says, explaining that he urged his father to put chlorine dioxide through proper scientific testing, with clinical trials, an institutional review board and safety protocols, to see if it would at least treat malaria.

Humble-Sanchez says his father isn’t in it for the money, and certainly isn’t living in the lap of luxury.
“He is altruistic,” Humble-Sanchez says. “He thinks it’s the right thing. He’s trying to do the right thing, to my thinking, the wrong way,” adding, “I can’t endorse him, but I can’t dismiss him.”

Humble-Sanchez acknowledges that telling tales of aliens doesn’t help the cause, saying, “He completely undermines any legitimate marketing strategy he should have.”

If Humble only peddled wacky B-movie sci-fi schlock and a general belief in the healing powers of chlorine dioxide, he might be easier to write off as a benign crackpot. But, cloaked in religious jargon, Genesis II doesn’t just market snake oil; it plays with people’s minds — one of the core reasons Humble supposedly left Scientology. He had, after all, rejected the teachings of that group’s “insane” leadership and their self-proclaimed monopoly on the truth.

But that’s exactly what’s on display in Genesis’s list of 32 reasons why MMS may not be working, a list that goes out of its way to blame the consumer.

“The problem is not that MMS doesn’t kill 95% of the known world’s diseases,” the list claims, “but that the person taking the protocols isn’t doing something correctly, or there is another factor stopping their health from ‘being restored.’”

One of these is “family pressure” — the presence of skeptical family members supposedly can prevent MMS from working. Negativity needs to be avoided. (In the Scientology lexicon, these kinds of naysayers are called “Suppressive Persons.”)

“Self-deception” also plays a role, which is why it’s important to continue drinking bleach even if you feel good. The church warns that “people can deceive themselves in thinking they are well when in fact they are still sick…Even after one’s health is restored, continue on the ‘maintenance doses’ and maintain a good diet to keep the immune system strong.”

“Trusting in the medical and pharmaceutical system” can also derail MMS’s efficacy, which is why it’s a good idea to stop taking prescription medicine or even visit a doctor while taking MMS.

Of course, lack of proper treatment can have serious consequences.

*****
Jennifer Hollis, who killed herself in May, posted videos documenting her chlorine dioxide treatment.
Jennifer Hollis, who killed herself in May, posted videos documenting her chlorine dioxide treatment.
YouTube screenshot
On March 17, less than two months before she killed herself, Jennifer Hollis posted the first of four YouTube videos documenting her treatment with Miracle Mineral Solution.

Dressed in blue-green scrubs from the medical assistant job she had so excitedly begun only a few months earlier, Hollis explains that it was time for her to finally admit that she had Lyme disease. She recorded the video from the home where she lived with her mother and sister, her parents having divorced in 2010. (Her parents did not respond to requests for comment.)

Hollis says she’d been on MMS for a year and improved to the point where she didn’t think she needed it anymore. But once she stopped, she became suicidal.

“My brain was just haywire,” she says.

Despite the subject matter, she seems upbeat, vibrant. She smiles.

Hollis had only turned 22 in January. An animal lover, Hollis included a donation drive for the HSPCA in her birthday celebration, rounding up a pile of toys and supplies. She spearheaded clothes-donation drives. It seems that she was always thinking about ways to help other people, which is one reason she was so excited to get her medical assistant job in June 2015.

“I am so grateful and ready to take on this position!!” she had announced on Facebook.

On a Facebook page launched during Hollis’s disappearance, which was “liked” by nearly 4,000 people, Hollis’s parents kept concerned parties abreast of the efforts to find her. There were also posts lovingly describing Hollis’s caring nature.

On May 20, ten days before Hollis’s body was found, her mother, Betsie, wrote about an interview she gave to the University of Houston Daily Cougar.

“The reporter asked me what kind of person Jennifer is,” Betsie wrote. “I told the man she’s the kind of person who would stop her car very late at night to save a hurt cat in the middle of a very busy street. She’s the kind of person who would put her 110 pound frame in danger with a man trying to harm his girlfriend. These are both true stories.”

A friend told the Press, “She was amazing. And she was so, so kind. Everything she did, she put 100 percent into it.”

The friend said that, while Hollis projected an air of happiness in the last few months of her life, she sensed, underneath, that something was wrong. Whatever it was, Hollis did not share that part of herself.

“It’s funny — you don’t know what’s inside of [someone], and why they’re hurting so much,” Hollis’s friend said.

Another friend told the Press that Hollis had felt suicidal in the fall of 2014, “shortly after she stopped taking MMS the first time. She bought a gun but later threw it away and instead cut her left wrist…Jen was very good at disguising her feelings and thoughts.”

On the Facebook page launched during Hollis’s disappearance, Hollis’s father noted that the page was being helped along by a family friend, Dawn Tollefson, who was “manning command central.”

“I am in awe at the drive that Betsie and Dawn have in this effort,” Hollis’s father wrote. (One of these efforts, per a post by Betsie, was the hiring of a psychic detective.)

In other Facebook posts, Betsie and Tollefson write prolifically of their belief in the ravages of Lyme disease, as well as their skepticism toward Western medicine.

Tollefson is a strident member of the anti-vaccination movement, and her posts convey a general belief in medical conspiracy theories.

In September, she told a reporter for a website called Community Impact that she had obtained vaccine exemptions from the school district her two autistic sons attend. But it’s not just autism — she’s claimed online that one of her sons also has epilepsy, OCD, panic attacks and possible gene mutations.

She’s written of her struggles raising special-needs children who weren’t just failed by modern medicine, but deliberately poisoned by Big Pharma. In one Facebook comment, she claims that “they’ve made over a million off of [my son] in his lifetime by making him sick.”

In October 2014, at the height of the Ebola scare, Tollefson posted an open letter to a U.S. congressman, questioning his allegiance.

“My son’s life has been ruined by the U.S. Government, namely the CDC, do you represent me or business?” she wrote. (Tollefson did not respond to requests for comment and made her Facebook page private after the Press tried to reach her.)

While Hollis was still missing, Betsie wrote, “Jennifer has been battling Lyme disease for about 18 months. It has been 18 months of hell for her and we suspect that she actually has had this illness for most of her life. For anyone who has Lyme or is close to someone with Lyme — they understand the deep depression that comes with it — there are no words possible to describe it.”

After Hollis’s death, Betsie wrote of what she felt was mainstream medicine’s relative shunning of Lyme: “I watch as public awareness of diseases like ebola and zika virus tower over Lyme yet the incidence and gravity of Lyme is astronomical compared to these and other illnesses.”

Betsie added, “Lyme suicide is almost as epidemic as the illness itself.”

In her first video documenting her MMS treatment, Hollis explains why she was making the videos, saying, “I really would like to have some help, and you know, people to rely on. And I guess I’ll rely on y’all, and so...this is making me really nervous.”

The following day, she posted another video explaining her regimen: 16 doses a day, which have helped with mood swings and anxiety. She described herself as “overemotional,” and said she suffered from memory loss and confusion. She had trouble with speech, concentration, and word recall.

“It has made a huge difference,” Hollis said of the MMS. She said that in recent weeks she had enough energy to go running and weight-lifting.

She said a lot of her friends and family “understand my symptoms. Some of them deny them, but I have the support of enough that understand. It does sound like, you know, it could just be in your head — but it’s not.”

She added, “We are very toxic and it’s not in your head and you’re not alone. And that’s the last thing I want someone to feel like — is that they’re alone and that they have no hope…I’ve given up so many times and then tried to regain…It’s been a rough road.”

Betsie’s description of Lyme disease clashes with mainstream views, which characterize Lyme as a relatively rare tick-borne ailment that is generally treatable with a few weeks of antibiotics. But within anti-vaccine, conspiratorial crowds, there is a belief in something called “chronic Lyme disease” that can cause severe psychological and physical problems.

According to the CDC, a small percentage of people who contract Lyme disease have lingering symptoms after standard antibiotic treatment. This is called post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome, and its cause is unknown.

“Most medical experts believe that the lingering symptoms are the result of residual damage to tissues and the immune system that occurred during the infection,” the CDC states. “…The good news is that patients with PTLDS almost always get better with time; the bad news is that it can take months to feel completely well.”

But in the videos, Hollis seems to be under the impression that her symptoms would never fully subside. She had to take extreme measures, which is why she went from drinking MMS to using it for “colon cleanses.” In one of her videos, Hollis says that the technique worked for a friend, who “had this huge, ginormous worm come out.”

By the time of her March 23 video, Hollis seemed to find this all very daunting.

“This is life right now and I need to figure it out,” Hollis says. “And if this stuff [Lyme] really is what it is, then I’ll probably be using it the rest of my life.”

In her final video, posted three weeks before her death, Hollis reveals that she’d actually tested negative for Lyme and had briefly doubted whether she actually had it. But she was going for another test, saying, “When I get my results back, I’ll be sure it’s Lyme.”

By the time those results — which are unknown — came back, she was already dead.

She explains that one of the reasons she hadn’t received all the benefits of MMS over the past year was that she had been drinking it in tea, which greatly diluted the chlorine dioxide. She was now mixing it in water.

Still, by May 12, the MMS had not cured whatever illness Jennifer Hollis had. And this, per church doctrine, was likely her fault.

“It sucks,” Hollis says in her first video. “It really does. I’m 22, in college, and sometimes I feel like I don’t even know where I am. Umm...so anyways…” Here she shakes her head, smiles nervously and sighs, before signing off: “This is Jen.”

Two months later, when police found Hollis’s body, they retrieved multiple suicide notes. In one, addressed to Betsie, Hollis wrote, “I don’t think I have Lyme. I’m sorry to disappoint.”

Jennifer Morgan Hollis finally found a way to end her suffering.

http://www.houstonpress.com/news/heres-why-authorities-want-to-stop-the-sale-of-jim-humbles-miracle-cure-8909556

Oct 22, 2016

Central Investigator Arrests Homeopathy Council Chief For Taking Rs 20 Lakh Bribe


Indo-Asian News Service
October 22, 2016

New Delhi: The CBI today arrested Central Council of Homeopathy President Ramjee Singh and another person on charges of accepting Rs 20 lakh in bribe to give a favourable inspection report for setting up of a homeopathy college.

Mr Singh, who was elected the council chief in 2009, was arrested along with Harishankar Jha during a raid by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) after a complaint. 

Sponsored Content by Taboola
How Plant Energy is Fighting Acne
BioClarity Skin Cream Subscription

Mr Singh has served both as president and secretary of the Homeopathic Association of India.

The Central Council of Homoeopathy, a statutory body under the Health and Family Welfare Ministry, is a regulatory authority for homoeopathy system of medicine.

It is entrusted with the work of maintaining the register of practitioners and the standards in homeopathic education.

http://m.ndtv.com/india-news/central-investigator-arrests-homeopathy-council-chief-for-taking-rs-20-lakh-bribe-1477696

Feb 22, 2016

CANCER 'VISIONARY' STANISLAW BURZYNSKI STANDS TRIAL FOR UNPRECEDENTED MEDICAL MALFEASANCE

TAMAR WILNERON
Newsweek
February 22, 2016

Traditional cancer treatments can involve all or a mix of morphine drips for pain, targeted radiation, surgery and tested medications. By comparison, the Texas Medical Board has alleged that Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski's "personalized cancer therapy" is a cocktail of medications which often haven't been tested together and can put a patient in greater danger then medically appropriate.

When Sandra Cohen was diagnosed with breast cancer, she did whatever she could to avoid chemotherapy. She took homeopathic remedies and herbs, and she changed her diet. She even tried laser therapy. Nothing worked. When she reached stage IV—the cancer metastasized to her lungs, clavicle bone and lymph nodes—her doctors were shocked. “The doctors here just kind of shook their heads and said, ‘How did you let this go so far?’” she recalls.

But she didn’t give up. Instead, she went to Stanislaw Burzynski.

As a young doctor in the 1970s, Burzynski began treating patients with antineoplastons, a collection of peptides, amino acids and amino acid derivatives he originally isolated from blood and urine. Since then, by his reckoning, he’s used the drugs to treat over 2,300 cancer patients—though he isn’t trained as an oncologist. He’s been the subject of laudatory documentaries and promoted by the likes of Dr. Mehmet Oz, the famous surgeon and TV personality, and Suzanne Somers, the actress-turned-naturopathic-medicine-advocate. “No one has worked harder, and no one has been more persecuted for his maverick approach,” Somers wrote in her bookKnockout: Interviews With Doctors Who Are Curing Cancer.

http://www.newsweek.com/stanislaw-burzynski-cancer-medical-malfeasance-429057

Nov 22, 2015

The dark side of alternative health treatments

Samantha Selinger-Morris
Daily Life
November 22, 2015

Why are some of us taking advice from "wellness" gurus instead of medically trained professionals?

Sarah Mathieson* just wanted the best chance to fall pregnant. So, she did what so many of us do. She researched her options, then visited a naturopath, who prescribed five bottles of supplements. And then, having developed joint pain, she went back ... and the naturopath prescribed another 16 bottles.

Dr Kerryn Phelps, a supporter of evidence-based complementary therapies and a former president of both the Australian Medical Association and the Australasian Integrative Medicine Association, treated Mathieson. "She came to see me saying she was feeling worse, terrible, achy, unwell." It turned out that Mathieson had ingested "toxic levels" of certain micronutrients.

Mathieson was one of the luckier ones. After stopping all of the supplements and taking a standard pre-pregnancy multivitamin, she went on to have a healthy pregnancy. But she is an example of a disturbing trend that Phelps sees in her practice: educated people – mostly women – falling victim to unqualified alternative health practitioners, many of whom they find online.

"They're inquisitive, looking for answers, not happy with 'Take this and go away' as an answer," says Phelps, who was motivated to write a book, Ultimate Wellness, in part because of her experiences with such patients. "They're prepared to invest time and energy and intellectual capital into their healthcare. But the question is, where are they getting their information from? In some cases, they're getting it from good websites on the net. And [in] some cases, from rubbish websites and unqualified practitioners."

Lately, alternative therapies have made front-page news. Jess Ainscough, the former journalist behind the globally popular blog The Wellness Warrior, died of cancer in February at the age of 30 after practising – and championing – a cancer-fighting regimen consisting largely of fruits, vegetables and coffee enemas.

And self-proclaimed Chinese healer Hongchi Xiao, who promotes his services on Facebook, made headlines in April when a diabetic seven-year-old Sydney boy, Aiden Fenton, died after attending one of Xiao's "slapping therapy" workshops. (Patients are slapped, often to the point of bruising, to "unblock poisons".)

Why are some of us taking advice from "wellness" gurus instead of medically trained professionals? Especially when so many of these gurus give advice that is, at the very least, highly suspect?

Dr Sue Ieraci, an emergency physician and executive member of Friends of Science in Medicine, a body that opposes scientifically unproven alternative health treatments, thinks many online wellness gurus garner huge followings because they make people feel powerful.

"It's not PC in our postmodernist society to get your simple answers from [medical] professionals, because that's paternalistic and 'giving in to the man'," says Ieraci. She says the online health gurus "make you feel empowered, because you're going against orthodoxy".

People who are struggling with illnesses that don't have a cure are particularly vulnerable. Like the followers of Kerri Rivera, an American woman who advocates, online and in her book Healing the Symptoms Known as Autism, the use of bleach enemas to "recover" children from autism. She believes that chlorine dioxide, an industrial bleaching agent, destroys the parasites that "cause" the condition. There is no medical basis for her beliefs and the FDA in the United States warns that it has the potential to cause nausea, severe vomiting and life threatening drops in blood pressure.

"People who are really struggling with those behavioural difficulties, it must be really challenging, so they're looking for someone to validate their struggle and give them something to blame," says Ieraci of the parents who follow gurus like Rivera.

"If you look at a lot of those sites, they're very good at courting them, saying how brave they are, and that they're the only people who don't believe the 'sheepol' – that's people who are sheep because they believe what they've heard [from mainstream medicine]."

Two years ago, a 55-year-old Brisbane man burnt a potentially fatal hole the size of a golf ball into the side of his head after he used a corrosive herbal treatment known as "black salve" – a paste often made from bloodroot and zinc chloride that is marketed as being able to "draw out" cancer – that is sold online as an alternative cancer remedy.

Phelps, who has treated patients who have used black salve, says "they're telling people what they want to hear, that they don't have to go through chemo or radiotherapy. And, to be honest, who wouldn't be terrified by the prospect of chemotherapy or radiotherapy?"

Dr Robert Walters, a Hobart GP, says Australia's medical culture is partly to blame for the current trend.

"Alternative practitioners ... often give the patient more time," says Walters, who has treated patients whose health has been made worse by seeing unqualified health practitioners. "This is where the medical profession has probably got to look at itself a little bit, because we're so busy, rushed, consultations are so short.

"If we spent more time explaining medicine – and medicine's not really a mystery, it's basically plumbing, you know – if you can explain disease process, explain what you need to worry about and what you don't need to worry about, and just spend a little bit of extra time with your patients, then I don't think they'll go looking for magic cures elsewhere with witchcraft."

Compounding these issues is the fact that alternative practitioners are largely unregulated. Chinese medicine practitioners, osteopaths and chiropractors are the only alternative health therapists required to be registered with the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA). The rest are accountable to no one particular body.

There are government departments and agencies, both state and federal, that can handle complaints, including the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC), and the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA). But red tape and a lack of resources – in 2013-14 the ACCC fielded 202,363 complaints (not all health-related), with just 27 prosecutions – means they are difficult to shut down.

It took authorities six years to stop Homeopathy Plus!, a company based on the NSW Central Coast, from selling a homeopathic whooping cough "vaccine". In October, the company and its director, Frances Sheffield, were banned from selling the products for five years by the Federal Court and ordered to pay fines totalling $138,000.

But this came after years of various orders and requests by the ACCC and the TGA. In one instance, Sheffield refused to publish a retraction regarding the claims she made on her website about the homeopathic vaccine, stating that she was not "advertising" but rather "providing evidence" about the company's homeopathic treatments.

Sheffield still features a section on her website called "Reversing Autism", with testimonies from parents who describe how their children's autism was cured with homeopathy. ("Melissa went from zero words to almost 50 in one day!" one parent writes.)

But people cannot be prosecuted for stating a scientifically unproven belief. "It's a little like trying to regulate religion, in a sense," says Adelaide-based lawyer Mal Byrne.

"Part of the difficulty is, how do you regulate something that's so vague?"

Byrne would know. Fourteen of his clients sued South Australian homeopath Monika Milka three years ago for allegedly infecting them with bacteria and permanently scarring them after she treated them with "biomesotherapy". This involved injecting saline solution and other substances under their skin. One client opted for the treatment to remedy arthritic pain. Others did so to boost a "general feeling of wellness". What they got instead were shame and isolation.

"You know, they were embarrassed," says Byrne. "A lot of them had to cover [their scarred skin]." Some clients needed antibiotics for years to eradicate the infection and were afraid to touch their children in case they infected them.

Milka denied the claims in court through her lawyer. She later settled with all 14 out of court but continues to work as a homeopath. In October, she published a claim on her Facebook page that her "Wellness Tonic" rid her late mother of cancer after chemotherapy failed to do so. This, says Byrne, is a "flagrant breach" of both the South Australian Code of Conduct for Unregistered Health Practitioners and laws regarding misleading and deceptive business conduct. (Authorities are now reviewing her Facebook page.)

So how can we determine which alternative health treatment – and practitioner – is safe and which isn't, particularly when some alternative health treatments that sound wacky have solid scientific backing?

For instance, the use of fecal microbial transplants – when a healthy person's stool is inserted into a sick person's colon – was lauded in The New England Journal of Medicine in 2013 after a study proved the therapy's effectiveness at fighting the bacteria Clostridium difficile. (Infection with the bacteria causes symptoms similar to Crohn's disease, and kills 15,000 people a year in the US alone.)

And, although controversial, some laboratory studies have shown that combining high doses of intravenous vitamin C with chemotherapy improved the effectiveness of chemotherapy in the treatment of some cancers.

Alarm bells should ring, says Phelps, if a non-medical practitioner discourages you from continuing care with your GP or medical specialist. People should also seek medical advice about any alternative therapy that carries even the slightest risk, taking particular care with the manipulation of bones and muscles and anything that is to be swallowed or that will pierce the skin.

We should also consider whether, in some situations, it might be emotional support we are seeking, says Dr Sarah McKay, a Sydney-based neuroscientist and mother of two who has studied online wellness gurus.

Noting that they often provide this role, she asks, "Who doesn't want a bit of mothering, a bit of TLC?" •

*Name has been changed.

http://m.dailylife.com.au/health-and-fitness/dl-wellbeing/the-dark-side-of-alternative-health-treatments-20151120-gl3v2w.html

Oct 13, 2015

The dark side of alternative medicine and holistic healing

SUSAN SERED
Salon
September 5, 2015


acupuncture
This article originally appeared on AlterNet.

Holistic healing sounds like a good thing. I certainly believe that each of us is far more than a cluster of discrete organs, bones and cells. I also believe that the thigh bone is connected to the hip bone; the mind and the body are a cohesive unit; that every illness experience is embedded in a wider social context; that environment matters; and that the manner in which a healer relates to a patient can result in widely different outcomes. And while we Americans may be suspicious that some brands of healing are nothing but quackery, unless the healer interferes with standard bio-medical treatment (for example, by telling patients they must stop receiving cancer chemotherapy) we tend to see holistic healing as benign. Even if it doesn’t “work” it helps people struggling with pain and disease feel better.

That assumption, I’ve come to see, needs to be looked at a bit more closely.

A number of years ago I conducted interviews with 46 Boston-area complementary and alternative medicine practitioners who told me during an initial phone call that they treat breast cancer patients.

Their healing modalities ranged from acupuncture to Zen shiatsu therapy and from homeopathy to past life regression.

All of the healers explained that bio-medical treatment alone is insufficient because it only targets the symptom (cancer) and not the underlying causes of the disease. (Only a very few of the healers actively discourage their patients from continuing bio-medical treatment.) The deeper, root causes identified by the healers cluster into a few categories:

*Elements of the modern environment or lifestyle that cause or contribute to the rise in rates of breast cancer; for example, air pollution, computers sending out electromagnetic rays which typically are parallel to the level of a woman’s breast, deodorants and antibiotics.

*Food and drink related causes such as alcohol abuse, dairy products, artificial sweeteners and gluten.

*Personal experiences and character traits including trauma, social isolation, lack of self-acceptance and feelings of resentment.

As I listened to healers (almost all of whom I very much liked on a personal level) I began to understand that through invoking these root causes the healers were actually reframing or expanding breast cancer from a discrete physical disease of a body part to a much larger problem potentially involving all areas of a woman’s life (and possibly her past lives as well).

This reframing is what I’ve come to call holistic sickening – a process in which the illness trajectory is expanded beyond a particular organ, body system or body part into diffuse environmental, lifestyle, personality and volitional issues. Holistic sickening is a necessary prerequisite to holistic healing: Perceiving the whole person as sick is the logical foundation for healing the whole person.

Happily, holistic healers, for the most part, absolve cancer patients of the kind of blame often heard in both popular and bio-medical discourses: if you have cancer that you must have done something wrong, either a crime of commission such as smoking or omission such as not going for timely mammograms (regardless of the obvious fact that mammograms do not prevent breast cancer). At the same time, however, holistic healing saddles patients with another set of responsibilities along the lines of: “If you have the power to heal yourself, then you must shoulder the blame for the extent to which you fail to do so.” This observation challenges the common notion that “if holistic healing doesn’t help at least it can’t hurt.” Because (for better or for worse) holistic sickening reveals an expanding constellation of unhealthy environment, food choices, life history and character traits, holistic healing becomes a lifetime journey or vocation that potentially engages every area of one’s being.

I was particularly struck by the gender-specific explanations offered by many of the healers. “Women [with breast cancer] are too good for their own good,” said a macrobiotic counselor. “They over nourish other people at their own expense. They are too ‘sweet’ and they also tend to eat too many sweet foods such as candies, chocolate and cakes.” According to a chakra-based energy healer, “Women with breast cancer are often nurturing of other people. [But] like they say on the airplanes, you have to put the oxygen mask on yourself before you help other people.” In this double-whammy, women are blamed both for behavior that many women see as of the highest possible moral value (caring for others) and blamed lack the self-discipline to avoid eating sweets.
For some of the practitioners, holistic explanations were framed in feminist terms. According to a past life regression therapist, “women want to be recognized and cherished, like everybody else. They want to be heard. Instead, they are shut down and not able to speak for themselves.” But more often, healers voiced nostalgia for patriarchal power and for conservative social arrangements, interpreting breast cancer as a symptom of changing gender roles and relations. A psychotherapist / energy healer explained that there is more breast cancer now because “women have to shut down the heart chakra in order to be super-women, having full time careers in addition to raising children and taking care of the home… There was a time that being a mother and nurturing and raising children was the best possible way to be; now economically it’s not good enough.”

Similarly, a holistic movement therapist, who herself is a cancer survivor, pointed out that, “As the women’s movement brought so much opportunity for women, it also brought women into an arena dominated by men – and we are simply wired differently. If women are not able to voice their truth or express their hearts, there is a build up AMA (yoga term for good) in the body that needs to find a way out…. According to Kundalini Yoga, women are 11 times more powerful, 11 times more wise and 11 times more sensitive than men. … Because of that yogic belief, if women are not given the opportunity to ‘show their true stuff’ there is a real stifling of energy. … Fifty years ago, women’s roles were different, but I wonder if perhaps they had more connection, more community, more support amongst each other. I am feeling like we are still needing that community of support but our lives are about 100 times busier.”

What, then, is a woman to do? As much as I dislike – and distrust — the cancer industry’s slash / poison / burn (surgery, chemo, radiation) approach and as much as I am nauseated by October’s pink ribbon extravaganzas, holistic sickening is no alternative. Indeed, in speaking with healers, I often felt that if a breast cancer patient had to resolve her issues with self-esteem, anger, nurturing, balancing work and family, and her relationship with her mother, not to mention transforming her “negative” or “toxic” thoughts into “positive energy” and (somehow magically) cleaning up air and water pollution she would easily die of old age before getting cured!

Susan Sered is a Professor of Sociology at Suffolk University in Boston. She has published six books, including "Uninsured in America: Life and Death in the Land of Opportunity" (University of California Press).

http://www.salon.com/2015/09/05/the_dark_side_of_alternative_medicine_and_holistic_healing_partner/?utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=socialflow