Nov 24, 2023

Parents Talk Back: Survivors of cults speak out

Aisha Sultan Syndicated Columnist
Washington Times Herald
November 22, 2023

Shelly Snow Pordea grew up in a fundamentalist religious sect.

When she was a child, her parents moved from her birthplace of St. Louis to Hammond, Indiana, to be near the First Baptist Church, an Independent Fundamental Baptist (IFB) megachurch then run by Jack Hyles.

Pordea, now 48, remembers her early life tightly revolving around this church.

The outside world, she was taught, was a threatening and scary place. Her parents subscribed to Hyles’ child-rearing methods, which promoted hitting children into submission — spanking babies as young as 6 months old. Pordea said her parents later told her that they kept rubber bands on her wrists when she was 2 years old, which they would snap against her skin to keep her in line. It wasn’t until Pordea was 14 and listening to a talk about promiscuous women during an IFB youth camp that she realized she had been sexually abused as a 4-year-old by a church member.

After the lecture, she confided the abuse to a camp counselor.

“I was told I was tainted and not clean anymore,” Pordea said. And she had been conditioned to believe it.

As a teenager, she tried to keep the peace in her family, especially after her brother ran away from home at 17. She attended the unaccredited Hyles-Anderson College, where she took classes that taught her it was a woman’s fault if a man strayed from his marriage.

Pordea got some physical distance from the church when she got married and moved overseas with her husband, although she was still deeply invested in it emotionally and mentally. Through the internet, Pordea discovered the accusations against Hyles of sexual scandals and financial misappropriation. She began connecting with former IFB members on social media, who shared their own stories of abuse.

Over time, the indoctrination began to unravel. By age 30, Pordea began to believe she had been raised in a cult. In 2013, the church leader Jack Schaap, Hyles’ son-in-law, was convicted of taking a 16-year-old across state lines to have sex with her. He was sent to federal prison.

“That was a point of no return,” Pordea said.

Pordea, who now lives in St. Peters, Missouri, joined forces with others in the cult survivor world to host a first-ever, live storytelling event last month in St. Louis. She wants to raise awareness of how some organizations use coercion, manipulation and undue influence in order to abuse and control people.

The movement began during the pandemic with the #IGotOut hashtag on social media, with people sharing their own experiences in cultic groups. A number of documentaries, podcasts and TV shows have brought awareness to the diverse range of such organizations. Some are political, religious or spiritual, while others revolve around doomsday prophesies, sex, self-help and even multilevel marketing.

Gerette Buglion, an author and executive director of IGotOut.org, was a teacher for 19 years before she became involved with a self-help group that eventually took over her life. She was introduced to the group leader by fellow teachers who were getting dream therapy sessions from him. Buglion began sessions as well, and the leader used the personal information she shared during therapy to slowly manipulate her and create dependence on him.

For 18 years, Buglion remained under the mind control of a charismatic fraud.

Almost 10 years ago, another woman in the organization described how the leader would yell at her for hours at a time for her perceived infractions. Because this information came from a person within the cult whom Buglion trusted and cared about, it created a big crack in her perception of the leader.

That was the opening she needed to get out.

Buglion, who has now heard hundreds of stories from survivors and their loved ones, said it is critical to try to maintain some kind of connection with a person you fear is being indoctrinated. She has since published the book “An Everyday Cult.” In it, she shows how anyone can be susceptible to narcissistic leaders and groups that claim to know the truth. They use natural human vulnerabilities and group dynamics to slowly take over a person’s critical thinking skills.

“The level of shame is very high for people coming out of cultic organizations,” she said. She was plagued with questions about how she, an educated person, could have let it get so bad and stayed for so long.

In recent years, many survivors have found connection through social media. Those connections, plus the pandemic lockdown and a boom in media programs about cults, have prompted many to reexamine their relationships with their tight-knit groups and leaders.

Pordea recalls watching Leah Remini’s documentary, “Scientology and the Aftermath,” with her husband, who hadn’t fully accepted the truth about his and Pordea’s upbringing.

Watching Remini’s story, the parallels to his own life finally hit him.

He looked at Pordea, stunned. “Oh my God, it was a cult,” he said.

Aisha Sultan is a St. Louis-based journalist who studies parenting in the digital age while trying to keep up with her tech-savvy children. Find her on Twitter: @AishaS.

https://www.washtimesherald.com/news/lifestyles/parents-talk-back-survivors-of-cults-speak-out/article_ad8b7ee0-7976-11ee-8dd7-5fef94095d61.html

Spanish police arrest cult leader for giving ‘purified mercury’ to followers

Police found 400 pounds of mercury in the extensive property with bunkers and clandestine labs


Anadolu Ajansı
Alyssa Mcmurtry
November 22, 2023

Spanish police arrest cult leader for giving 'purified mercury' to followers.

OVIEDO, Spain

Spanish authorities have arrested the leader of a so-called cult accused of administering 'purified mercury' to his followers, police announced on Wednesday.

The man, known as Trascendencia Total (Total Transcendence), faces charges such as crimes against public health, the environment, workers' rights, moral integrity, and unlawful association, police say.

The leader is said to have operated his Mahasandhi Foundation out of the small desert town of Abanilla, Murcia for the past 15 years.

During the raid on its 10-hectare (24-acre) complex replete with cave dwellings, warehouses, temples, bunkers, and clandestine laboratories and another warehouse, police discovered 180 kg (400 pounds) of mercury.

Mercury is a controlled substance and investigators suspect the community procured it on the dark web. Police allege the detainee aimed to purify it with alchemy to create energizing and healthy elixirs.

Police say the leader asked his followers to work with the mercury. They began showing symptoms of mercury poisoning, which can include muscle weakness, numbness, poor coordination, memory problems as well as trouble speaking, hearing, or seeing.

As a means of financing the community, they would also sell what they called "elixirs" to herbalists, online or to visitors.

Total Transcendence would also give out several types of "unhealthy psychoactive drugs" to followers during rituals, police said, with the intention of "subduing the will of the consumers."

He spent long periods locked up in his cave home alongside several women, while other followers lived in caves nearby. Their devotion to him was so strong that many cut ties with their families to serve their "master," police said.

Local broadcaster La 7 reported that when the police arrested Total Transcendence, he had taken a vow of silence and communicated with the authorities by writing on a chalkboard.

Police also accuse him of violating labor laws by making his followers work long hours to satisfy his or the foundation's needs. He also received many donations, which police said, "boosted his wealth in a relatively short time."

Mercury presents a significant risk to both human health and the global environment, remaining in circulation for thousands of years, according to the European Environment Agency.

Police alleged that Total Transcendence's community dumped the mercury residue into a septic tank.

During the raid, police found €90,000 ($98,000) in cash, a revolver and significant amounts of marijuana.

Total Transcendence has been remanded in provisional custody and police have closed off his complex and a related warehouse. The foundation has taken down its website and social media presence.

In October, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) warned about the link between Ayurvedic products and heavy metal poisoning. A traditional system of healing from India, some texts and branches tout the healing benefits of so-called "purified mercury."



https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/spanish-police-arrest-cult-leader-for-giving-purified-mercury-to-followers/3062101

Nov 23, 2023

The Jehovah's Witnesses turned preaching into a metrics game that broke up marriages and made careers, but they just changed their door-to-door strategy for the first time since 1920

PETER SMITH AND THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Fortune
November 22, 2023

Jehovah’s Witnesses are well-known for proselytizing door-to-door and handing out their literature on city streets. Less known to the general public, their adherents have been required for the past century to make regular reports to their congregation’s leaders on how many hours they put into such ministry.
Those hourly reports were a key metric for a congregation’s spiritual vitality and a factor in deciding who rose to leadership. Former adherents tell of pressure to meet these quotas and guilt when they didn’t.

But in a historic shift, that practice ended this month.

For the first time since 1920, leaders of the Jehovah’s Witnesses have removed the hours-reporting requirement for rank-and-file adherents.

“Our ministry involves much more than counting time,” Samuel Herd, a member of the denomination’s Governing Body, said in announcing the policy change to applause at the October annual meeting of the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania, a legal entity central to the Jehovah’s Witnesses’ work.

Herd said the Governing Body is “confident that you dear ones will continue to render whole-souled service,” motivated not by obligation but devotion to God, whom they call Jehovah. But he acknowledged leaders would have to adapt.

“You will have to know the flock well,” he said. “Evaluating a congregation’s spiritual health or a brother’s qualifications to serve (in leadership positions such) as an elder or ministerial servant will not simply be a matter of computing averages, time spent in the ministry, literature placements and so forth.”

The video of the meeting, held in Newburgh, New York, was publicly posted by the organization in early November, though leaked recordings circulated for weeks earlier on unofficial websites.

“This is one of the biggest changes I ever remember” in the organization, said former elder Martin Haugh of York Haven, Pennsylvania.

Removal of the hours requirement applies to “publishers,” or rank-and-file adherents involved in active ministry. They will now only need to file monthly reports saying whether they’ve conducted any evangelistic activity and Bible studies, without specifying hours.

Those who sign up for more extensive service, known as “pioneers” or “missionaries,” will continue to record their hours.

Hours fell since the pandemic

Skeptical former adherents, however, are speculating different motives are at play — that adherents’ ministry hours have dropped so noticeably, particularly since the pandemic.

When numbers were growing, “it was always brought up at meetings or in their publications to show the growth of the organization,” said Mitch Melin of Washington state, a former adherent now working to bring awareness to what he calls the “darker side” of the organization, such as its control of Witnesses and the practice of shunning certain members. He speculated that “if they’re declining, it might be embarrassing to show” the numbers.

Jarrod Lopes, a spokesman for Jehovah’s Witnesses based at their world headquarters in New York state, disputed this notion. He said ministry time had been increasing yearly until the pandemic, peaking above 2 billion hours worldwide. While the hours are below pre-pandemic levels, he said they began rising from 1.4 billion in 2021 to 1.5 billion hours in 2022 as Witnesses resumed door-to-door visits and other ministry.

Former elder Haugh, who left over what he saw as the denomination’s mishandling of sexual abuse and other matters, said the hours requirement was once central in adherents’ lives.

“It showed you how loyal you were to Jehovah by how much time was put in,” he said.

Haugh recalled how a regional supervisor yelled at elders if their congregation’s performance lagged. Haugh said marriages broke up over spouses’ different levels of commitment, and people who were judged as failing at ministry would spiral into depression. “Now they don’t have to have that stigmatization that they’re not putting in the hours,” he said.

On a recent weekday afternoon, Jehovah’s Witnesses were handing out literature to passers-by at various downtown locations in Pittsburgh — the 19th century birthplace of the movement.

Those interviewed said they planned to do as much ministry as ever and hadn’t focused on the hours. “It doesn’t affect our day-to-day life,” said Chuck Ghee, a local elder. “We give the best out of our heart.”

Revising the date of the end time

The Governing Body also devoted part of the annual meeting to revising its interpretation of biblical prophecies about the end times — a paramount focus of Jehovah’s Witnesses.

The Governing Body now accepts that even in the final countdown to Armageddon, nonbelievers might still accept the truth and be saved. That reverses a previous understanding that, once an apocalyptic Great Tribulation gets underway, it would be too late.

That announcement, not yet formally made public, has also been circulating online on the same unofficial sites that distributed authentic recordings of the announced policy change on tracking hours.
“Will all those living during the Great Tribulation have a full opportunity to decide either for the kingdom or against it?” Governing Body member Geoffrey Jackson said at the annual meeting.

“We don’t know, and we don’t need to know because we’re not the judges,” Jackson said. “We know that Jehovah and Jesus are merciful, that they will always do the right thing.”

Earlier leaders of the organization had raised expectations for apocalyptic events in specific years, such as 1975, which failed to materialize. Current teaching still puts a strong emphasis on the end times, but without predicting specific dates.

Governing Body member Jeffrey Winder said at the annual meeting that God reveals truth gradually and that the body is happy to have its understandings corrected.

“Knowing this, we are not embarrassed about adjustments that are made, nor is an apology needed for not getting it exactly right previously,” he said.

Lopes declined to comment on the unreleased teaching videos before their scheduled release in January, following their translation into more than 200 languages spoken by adherents. While he neither confirmed nor disputed the videos’ authenticity, he did say unofficial sites impinge on copyright when they distribute Watch Tower videos without authorization.

Attacks and government bans

The changes come at a turbulent time for Jehovah’s Witnesses. Worship gatherings in India and Germany suffered fatal attacks in the past year from former participants. Believers in Russia, where the denomination is banned, face persecution.

The Jehovah’s Witnesses faces intense scrutiny worldwide over the handling of child sexual abuse. A Pennsylvania grand jury has charged 14 men since 2022 with sexual abuse within the organization.

The denomination counts 8.7 million adherents worldwide, with 1.2 million in the United States.

The changes in teaching and the practice of recording hours, taken together, can be seen as a “relaxation of the sectarian identity of the group,” said Mathew Schmalz, a professor of religious studies at the College of Holy Cross in Worcester, Massachusetts.

On the one hand, “it’s hard to see the Witnesses becoming a mainstream church, because it would lose some of its appeal to being the possessors of biblical truth” to the exclusion of others, Schmalz said. On the other hand, the organization wants “to have the public take them seriously as a religious organization.”

Former elder Haugh said the changes don’t make up for failures in reforming the handling of abuse or for battling former adherents and critics in court and other venues. “They may be nicer to their own members, but they’ve become even more against their former members,” he said.

Associated Press religion coverage receives support through the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content.

https://fortune.com/2023/11/22/jehovahs-witnesses-preaching-metrics-policy-change/

Nov 21, 2023

A Silicon Valley 'Orgasm Cult' Has Been Sued for Sex Trafficking


A former employee for OneTaste alleges she was forced to have sex with potential investors and other members of the group

 

Rolling Stone

EJ DICKSON

NOVEMBER 21, 2023

 

THE LEADERS OF OneTaste, a sexual wellness organization and so-called “orgasm cult” that briefly enjoyed popularity in the mid-2010s, have been charged with sex trafficking, according to court documents.

Nicole Daedone and Rachel Cherwitz, the former CEO and head of sales for the now-defunct startup OneTaste, are being sued by a former employee in the Southern District of New York for allegedly “[using] means of force, threats of force, fraud, and a variety of other forms of coercion” to compel the employee to “engage in commercial sex acts as a form of forced labor for Defendants.”

The former employee, who is named in the suit only as Jane Doe, alleges that she was “forced to participate in unwanted commercial sexual acts with her co-workers, as a ‘requirement’ for her employment” and to have sex with potential customers to entice them to give money to the company. The suit alleges that Daedone and Cherwitz subjected OneTaste members and employees to “economic, sexual, emotional, and psychological abuse, surveillance, indoctrination, and intimidation.”

Founded in 2004 by Daedone, OneTaste was marketed as a sexual wellness company that peddled the benefits of orgasmic meditation, or “OM-ing.” OM-ing, as defined by Daedone and OneTaste, involved stroking a woman’s clitoris and vulva in a specific fashion for fifteen minutes. Courses were pricey, with some costing upwards of about $7,500; men were also charged extra. According to Daedone, the practice was intended to strengthen women’s sexual lives, allowing them to connect more easily with their sexual partners.

OneTaste received a great deal of press in the early 2010s, including a viral TEDTalk by Daedone and a 2013 longform Gawker investigation by Nitasha Tiku, called “My Life With the Thrill-Clit Cult.” Media coverage of OneTaste largely painted it as a bizarre, if not largely innocuous, organization on the fringes of Silicon Valley, and it ultimately expanded to various major cities across the United States, reportedly pulling in an estimated $12 million in revenue by 2017.

In June 2018, however, Bloomberg published an in-depth expose of OneTaste, in which 16 former employees and OneTaste members alleged that the group “resembled a kind of prostitution ring — one that exploited trauma victims and others searching for healing.” “In some members’ experiences, the company used flirtation and sex to lure emotionally vulnerable targets. It taught employees to work for free or cheap to show devotion. And managers frequently ordered staffers to have sex or OM with each other or with customers,” reporter Ellen Huet wrote. (OneTaste denied the allegations at the time, calling them “outrageous.”) The expose also revealed that an employee had previously sued the company for suffering sexual assault and harassment on the job; though they denied the allegations, it resulted in an out-of-court settlement in 2015.

The exposes prompted multiple documentaries about OneTaste, most notably the 2022 Netflix documentary Orgasm Inc: The Story of OneTaste. It also prompted an FBI investigation, culminating in Daedone and Cherwitz being indicted on forced labor charges in June 2023. Prosecutors alleged that Daedone and Cherwitz intentionally targeted vulnerable individuals to recruit them to join the organization, instructing them to engage in sexual activity and to live communally with other members. The two have pleaded not guilty, and each face a maximum of 20 years in prison if convicted.

The latest lawsuit expands on these allegations, with Jane Doe alleging that she was employed by the organization between 2008 and 2014 as an audiovisual specialist, living and working with other OneTaste employees at the company’s San Francisco headquarters. “During her time with OneTaste, Jane Doe was forced to engage in sexual intercourse with co-workers as a way of solving problems in the workplace,” the lawsuit reads, adding that she was “subjected to verbal abuse, threats of castigation from the OneTaste community, name calling and financial punishments if she did not participate in the “OM” sessions or in the company policy that she have sex with other members to ‘calm work tensions.'”

The suit alleges that the company also forced the plaintiff to engage in sex acts with potential customers as a way of encouraging them to spend money on classes. “When OneTaste members declined to participate in sexual activities, Defendants and their employees and agents chastised, humiliated, embarrassed and withheld pay from OneTaste members,” the lawsuit says.

Daedone and Cherwitz did not respond to a request for comment.

https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/onetaste-orgasm-cult-lawsuit-sex-trafficking-1234890660/

 

The False Prophet of Edmonton


In a suburban industrial park, John de Ruiter built up a spiritual movement, mashing up Christian theology and New Age mysticism. Today, eight former followers claim he brainwashed them into sex. The case against him will test the boundaries of consent.

Maclean's

Luc Rinaldi

The Oasis Centre is a luxuriant aberration on the industrial edge of northwest Edmonton. Neighboured by window-less warehouses and car dealerships, the $7-million complex comprises a palatial banquet hall built of cream-coloured brick, a 200-car parking lot and a thicketed garden with a stone patio and lily-padded pond. When the property opened in 2007, it became a popular venue for conferences and weddings—newlyweds would pose for photos in front of its sleek wood-and-glass facade. But the Centre's core function was very different: to serve as the headquarters of a mysterious spiritual community called the College of Integrated Philosophy.

In the 2010s, at the peak of the College's popularity, as many as 400 members gathered at the Oasis Centre several times a week. They'd file through the marble-floored foyer, past the 1,300-gallon koi aquarium and into the two-floor auditorium. They'd jockey for front-row seats before John de Ruiter, a striking fiftysomething spiritual teacher, would step on stage and settle into a padded chair at the front of the room. On either side of him, massive projector screens would stream a close-cropped feed of his face: a shock of flowing white hair, a sculpted brow furrowed in thought, crystalline blue eyes gazing at the crowd. Then, one by one, his followers would approach a microphone to seek guidance.

De Ruiter's faithful brought him their despair and uncertainty. They spoke of failed marriages and stalled careers, crises of identity and bouts of aimlessness. Sometimes their questions were as simple as "Should I stay at my job?" Others rambled for hours, confessing their darkest demons and thoughts of suicide. In response, de Ruiter might simply stare in silence, as if answering their queries on another plane of communication. Occasionally, he let a single tear roll down his cheek. If he offered a verbal reply, he spoke slowly and softly, and his message was usually terse and cryptic. "When you encounter what I am, that's a parched, thirsty heart encountering an ocean," went a typical reply.

De Ruiter claimed to be Christ reincarnated and, like Jesus, he had an entourage of apostles who wept and supplicated and wrote down his every word. He amassed his flock by holding meetings all over the world—the U.S., Israel, India, Australia and across Europe—and encouraging audiences to follow him to Edmonton. Jeanne Parr, a CBS News correspondent, made the move in the late 1990s, intending to film a documentary about him; her son Chris Noth, who played Mr. Big on Sex and the City, occasionally accompanied her to meetings. Parr introduced de Ruiter to future followers including Carl Mindell, a New York psychiatrist who told the Edmonton Journal, "I think he is the most powerful spiritual teacher I've ever seen."

He was also slender and handsome, an object of open romantic desire among some followers, who gossiped about his so-called "chosen women"—the attractive acolytes to whom he paid special attention. Against the odds, they seemed to be summoned to the microphone at his meetings over and over, and he was well-known to have sexual relationships with some of them. "I have moved in being with women other than my wife," reads his website. "This means being together physically and sexually." An ex-follower told me a male member once said he wished de Ruiter would choose men too.

Sex was central to de Ruiter's teachings. He distinguished between superficial lust and a higher form of sexual energy that he said resided in the heart, and claimed his relationships were inspired by a supernatural calling.

Now, more than 25 years after de Ruiter began amassing his following, some of his "chosen women" are telling a different story. Over the past year, eight of them have approached Edmonton police, alleging that de Ruiter used his position of clerical power to make them believe that having sex with him was an avenue to enlightenment. According to them, de Ruiter was not a godlike sage expanding the bounds of love and sex—though he may have believed he was—but a serial predator.

In January of this year, police arrested de Ruiter and his wife, Leigh Ann. He now faces eight counts of sexual assault against eight separate women; she faces six, for allegedly facilitating encounters between her husband and his accusers. They've both pleaded not guilty and are out on bail, tending to a shrunken flock of diehard followers in the wilderness of northern Alberta while awaiting their trial. They declined interview requests through a spokesperson. But earlier this year, speaking to media after de Ruiter's first court appearance, his lawyer, Dino Bottos, outlined his theory of the case. The women consented to sex with de Ruiter, he said, but "have now claimed, years afterward, that their consent was really nullified and not valid, because they were somehow placed under his spell, or that he was somehow deceiving them into believing that they should sleep with him in order to find a higher state of consciousness."

There's nothing original about de Ruiter's alleged crimes. Throughout history, gurus and spiritual guides have leveraged power to exercise sexual control, and their misdeeds often go unpunished. The Indian mystic Osho, Children of God founder David Berg, the influential Zen master Joshu Sasaki—all were accused, over decades, of perverting religious tenets to legitimize abuse, telling followers that sexual submission was a way to advance their spiritual training. None were ever criminally charged.

Until recently, police, prosecutors and even victims themselves often did not characterize these experiences as sexual assault. There was a sense that, by having the bad sense to join groups like these of their own volition, victims were at least somewhat complicit in their misfortune. Carol Merchasin, a lawyer with the British firm McAllister Olivarius who specializes in cases of sexual misconduct in spiritual communities, says that many of her clients initially don't realize they've been abused. "When people are psychologically manipulated, when they are in these situations where they trust someone else, it is not that easy to recognize," she says. "I've had people take years and years to actually understand that what happened to them was rape."

Our collective understanding of consent has evolved quickly since the birth of the #MeToo movement. Today, there is a greater recognition that the power imbalance between spiritual leaders and their followers makes these relationships ripe for abuse. Survivors are more willing to report their stories, and people are more likely to believe them.

Lately, we've begun to get a sense of how courts will treat such charges. In 2020, Keith Raniere, the leader of the the celebrity-studded sex cult NXIVM, was sentenced to 120 years in prison for starving his female followers, depriving them of sleep, blackmailing them, branding them as slaves and telling them that yogic sex with him was the only way to atone for wrongs they'd committed in past lives. Though de Ruiter's alleged crimes are less extreme than Raniere's, the central question in his case is similar: did he, through deceit and manipulation, establish such a firm grip on his followers' psyches that their free will was nullified?

"As lawyers, we can't bring frivolous claims, but we can push the envelope," says Merchasin. "When charges like these are successful, they set a precedent that other cases and other judges, even in other jurisdictions, can use. All of that moves the needle."

Wherever the law lands, the decision is likely to shed new light on questions of consent: what it is, when it can and cannot be granted, and how and when it can be revoked.

***

John de Ruiter always had messianic delusions. The second of four children born to Dutch immigrants, he grew up attending a Pentecostal church in Edmonton. Once, at a Christian youth rally, a self-styled prophet picked him out of the crowd and said, "You will be a mighty man of God." As a teenager, de Ruiter says, he had a spiritual awakening. "I was unexpectedly gifted with a knowing and an experience of oneness with the source," he wrote in a self-published book, Unveiling Reality. "My awareness of reality expanded in ways that I could have never imagined."

The sacred sensation vanished inexplicably when he was 18, throwing him into a crisis of faith. Determined to rekindle it, he started sampling a bizarre assortment of spiritual practices: listening to audio tapes of the Bible at high speed, and dumpster-diving and sleeping in churchyards to emulate the life of an ascetic.

In 1981, de Ruiter, then 22, became a regular at a local Christian bookstore, buying out-of-print books by obscure theologians. His piercing blue eyes and ecclesiastical aptitude attracted the attention of the shop's 18-year-old clerk, Joyce. When he told her he wanted to become a pastor, she took it as fate—she'd always wanted to be a preacher's wife. They married the following summer and eventually had three children: Naomi, Nicolas and Nathaniel.

De Ruiter supported his young family by making orthopedic shoes, a craft he'd learned from his cobbler father, and working as a pastor's assistant at a Lutheran church. He quickly developed a reputation as the parish eccentric. During one sermon, he repeated "God wants to set you free" ad nauseam. During another he stated, "God has no word for you," and stood at the lectern in silence for several minutes. Invited to give his testimony—a common practice in which evangelicals tell the story of how they came to Christ—de Ruiter spoke for nine hours.

Church leadership dismissed de Ruiter in 1987; his style proved too bizarre for the congregation. When he left, several couples followed him—a grassroots community that formed the nucleus of what he would eventually build. They met in private homes, bookstores and acupuncture clinics to analyze the Book of Revelation and discuss their dreams. Among these early followers was de Ruiter's first true devotee: Joyce's brother-in-law, Bob Emmarzael. The two men discussed theology late into the evening several times a week, nurturing one another's most outlandish beliefs. Emmerzael suggested that de Ruiter might be the messiah prophesied in the Book of Isaiah; de Ruiter claimed Jesus had appeared to him thousands of times and "transferred who he is over to me."

Throughout the mid-1990s, de Ruiter picked up techniques that would help him convince others that the Son of God had, in fact, returned to life in the form of an Edmonton shoemaker. For two years, he met almost daily with a New Ager named Boots Beaudry, who taught him what was to become one of his most effective tools: prolonged, hypnotic staring. After several minutes of unbroken eye contact, Beaudry explained, people start to see lights, colours and visions.

Scientific research backs this up. A 2015 study published in the peer-reviewed journal Psychiatry Research found that 90 per cent of subjects began hallucinating after staring at another person's face for 10 minutes in a dimly lit room.

De Ruiter introduced the practice to his meetings, replacing Bible study with hours of silent staring. Word spread about the gazing guru, and inquisitive newcomers started showing up. Catherine Auman, an L.A.-based licensed psychotherapist who attended a series of his sessions in 2000, told me that the first time she looked into de Ruiter's eyes, she started gasping involuntarily. "There was just this energy," she says. "He looked at me and I started hallucinating. I saw this halo around his head, and then I saw a lion. My internal dialogue was, am I going crazy?" And at exactly that moment, she says, de Ruiter held her gaze and said, "Now you're really seeing."

Soon de Ruiter was holding four meetings a week. Charging two dollars for admission, he made enough money to quit shoemaking and devote himself to building a spiritual empire. In 1998, he embarked on his first world tour, holding low-budget lectures where he sold pamphlets, books, CDs, cassette tapes and flattering pictures of himself. Then came multi-day seminars and retreats, earning him hundreds of dollars a head. His operation would later include social media, a YouTube channel and a paid streaming service called John de Ruiter TV.

At the same time, de Ruiter's philosophy continued to evolve, becoming a mix of messianic messaging and New Age psychobabble. It had a peculiar appeal for disaffected churchgoers and aging hippies. He denigrated organized Christianity as "Satan's masterpiece" and began dabbling in the occult, including hypnosis, bilocation and astral projection—the idea that one's consciousness can travel beyond the physical body. He espoused a Zen-like non-attachment to the material world. He told his faithful to live with "core-splitting honesty" and surrender to the truth. Followers were not to trust their intuitions, feelings or thoughts. They were to trust John.

***

From the beginning, there were those who worried about the dangers of vesting so much power in one man. In the late 1990s, Stephen Kent, a sociology professor at the University of Alberta, watched the group grow from a distance. He met with de Ruiter and his inner circle and advised them to be careful. Kent had studied alternative spiritual movements, and he knew that, without checks and balances, they could inflict psychological damage on adherents. They could also lead, in the worst cases, to tragedies like the Jonestown massacre in Guyana in 1978, when more than 900 followers of cult leader Jim Jones poisoned themselves on his orders. "I hope John is able to maintain his delicacy when dealing with his followers," Kent told the Calgary Herald in 1997.

Yet de Ruiter's hold on his followers only kept growing. In 1999, a young woman named Marian Vasquez flew from Montreal to Vancouver to attend one of de Ruiter's four-day seminars. She was feeling unmoored and depressed—she'd just endured a painful breakup and miscarriage—and she hoped he might be able to help. During her first meeting, she wept and felt a sense of ecstasy. "It was very moving for me," she says. "I didn't know why, but I thought, maybe this is a sign." By the end of the week, she'd decided to move to Edmonton.

Within a matter of months, Vasquez developed a deep devotion to de Ruiter. She attended multiple meetings a week, had lunch with him, sent him letters and believed they were destined for a closer relationship. Her friends enviously told her she was lucky to have such a strong connection with him. She wasn't the only one. Another member, a wealthy woman from the U.S., had purchased and renovated a large house in Edmonton—she told Vasquez that she and de Ruiter would live in it together. "For three months, she was totally convinced that she was going to marry him," says Vasquez, who had also begun to hear rumblings that de Ruiter was cheating on Joyce with other followers.

By then, Joyce had heard rumours that her husband was involved with two women, sisters Katrina and Benita von Sass. They were the daughters of a wealthy Calgary businessman, Peter von Sass, who had invited de Ruiter to run a retreat near Edmonton. When Joyce confronted him, he denied it. But one evening in November of 1999, as she and de Ruiter were chatting and smoking cigarettes in their kitchen, he started talking to her about a concept he called "weaning": discarding physical, emotional and sexual needs and desires, destroying one's artificial sense of self and leaving only enough space for truth. De Ruiter pointed out how well Joyce had weaned off old visions of their life together. The staring, the kooky mysticism, the way de Ruiter's followers fawned over him—it wasn't the simple Christian existence she'd imagined. Wouldn't it be the ultimate act of weaning, he suggested, if she were to allow him to take two more wives?

Joyce pressed him on what he meant, but de Ruiter refused to say anything more. So she confronted him in the one place where he had no choice but to listen. During a meeting that December, she walked up to the questioner's mic and began reading from a sheet of paper. "My sweetie, you are not God. You, more than anyone, have been sucked into a powerful deception," she said. "Sex with Benita and Katrina is not truth. Can you just, for a tiny moment, look at what is happening to you?"

De Ruiter didn't offer an explanation until a subsequent meeting. When he did, he said he was doing what he knew to be true, regardless of the toll it would take on Joyce, their children and the community. "It didn't have to do with their looks, their heart, their age," he said to the crowd, referring to the von Sass sisters. "It had only to do with what arose from within my innermost."

De Ruiter's followers were stunned. No one had ever challenged him like that. Joyce initiated divorce proceedings, underwent anti-cult counselling and, several years later, moved to the Netherlands with the children. Plenty of others left the group, too, some in solidarity with Joyce, others because they felt de Ruiter had strayed from his Christian roots. Those who remained for subsequent meetings approached the mic with questions like, "If you say people have to be happy with less and less, why are you taking more and more women?" To which he responded, "If I explained it to you, you wouldn't understand." For the first time, de Ruiter was losing hold of his flock.

As he began to split his time between the von Sass sisters—spending one week with Benita and the next with Katrina—he became more standoffish, devoting little attention to followers outside of official meetings. From then on, photos taken inside meetings needed to be approved by group volunteers or the von Sasses, who became de Ruiter's de facto assistants, tour managers and meeting administrators.

Vasquez hoped de Ruiter would explain how his new persona and unorthodox love triangle all fit within some greater plan, but she eventually lost hope she'd ever get answers. Whenever someone asked de Ruiter about Joyce or his relationships with the von Sasses, he offered a nonsensical response or stared at them in total silence. "I got tired of the evasion," says Vasquez. She left in 2002.

Two years later, one of Stephen Kent's graduate students, Paul Joosse, started studying the group. He wanted to understand what drew people to de Ruiter—and why, even when some abandoned him, others stuck around. Attending meetings and interviewing members, Joosse arrived at several theories. He believed de Ruiter's intense staring not only spawned visions but was also a shortcut to a false sense of intimacy. His followers projected profundity onto de Ruiter's silence. When de Ruiter did speak, his words were so vague that they had the effect of a well-written horoscope: generic to outsiders, powerfully specific to believers. De Ruiter's most fervent acolytes also provided social cues that underscored his special status: they compared him to Jesus, cried in his presence and swapped stories of his supposed clairvoyance.
Not everyone felt the pull, of course. "Thousands of people have gone to de Ruiter's meetings and decided that it wasn't for them," says Joosse. "Those who are staying are those who have chosen to stay." Once the true believers bought into de Ruiter's claim that he was truth itself, they were primed to cling to him. In the 2000s, de Ruiter was reportedly earning more than $232,000 per year, plus five-figure donations from his followers. Once the Oasis Centre opened in 2007, it could fetch up to $13,000 per wedding or conference. By 2009, de Ruiter was worth an estimated $9 million, and lived like it, flying first class, riding a Royal Enfield motorcycle and purchasing a massive $75,000 truck.

In 2009, another debacle cast de Ruiter's relationship with the von Sass sisters in a new light. That year, de Ruiter took a vacation to Egypt. Benita thought he went with Katrina; Katrina thought he went with Benita. In reality, he was travelling with Leigh Ann Angermann, a German woman who'd recently moved to Edmonton to follow de Ruiter. After their return, de Ruiter separated from the sisters, and marrid Angermann. The sisters later filed lawsuits against de Ruiter, claiming that as common-law spouses and former employees of the Oasis Centre, they were owed money. They also claimed that Benita had been fired without cause, and that Katrina paid part of the down payment on de Ruiter's $920,000 suburban house.

When de Ruiter first admitted to sleeping with the von Sass sisters in 1999, his followers treated the relationships as affairs between consenting adults. In her suit, however, Benita framed them as something more sinister. "The defendant convinced me to sexually submit to him, reminding me that this was 'God's will,' " she wrote. "The defendant stated he was the 'Christ on Earth' and that defying him was to defy truth, goodness and God. Accordingly, I obeyed and submitted." De Ruiter denied the allegations. Benita von Sass settled out of court for an undisclosed sum, and has not had any involvement with de Ruiter or his organization since. The non-disclosure terms of her settlement agreement prevent her from providing commentary to journalists.

Benita von Sass's accusations were a clear omen. But unlike the allegations de Ruiter would face in the future, there were no criminal charges. He did lose another chunk of his followers, however. It was only a few years until he'd test the loyalty of those who remained.

In the mid-2000s, a young woman named Anina—whose surname I've withheld at the request of her family—attended one of de Ruiter's meetings in England. Growing up in South Africa, Anina had always been interested in spirituality, and in de Ruiter she saw a powerful teacher. So, like others before her, she moved to Edmonton. Before long, she was a devoted member, attending multiple meetings a week.

In March of 2014, when Anina was 32, she suddenly stopped showing up. Three days later, her car was found parked on the shoulder of a rural road. Seven weeks after that, her body was found in the woods near Nordegg, Alberta, not far from a resort where the group held overnight retreats.

The police ruled it a likely suicide, but Anina's family suspected there was more to the case. In diary entries leading up to her death, Anina had written extensively about de Ruiter. "John taught me how to make love," she wrote in one passage. "We moved in sexuality together," read another. Elsewhere in the diary, Anina tried to grapple with the aftermath of what seemed to be an encounter with de Ruiter. "The next day I tried to make sense of why he moved that way with me," Anina wrote. "I was wondering what the consequences would be, whether he is doing this with everyone." Anina's relatives pushed police to conduct a criminal investigation, but prosecutors deemed the diary entries too vague to use as evidence against de Ruiter, who denied having a sexual relationship with her. Once again, no criminal charges were laid.

The pressure continued to build in 2017, when a Danish woman wrote a lengthy Facebook post detailing a troubling encounter she'd had with de Ruiter and Leigh Ann. The previous September, she claimed, they had invited her to their home, an elegant four-bedroom bungalow on a tree-lined lot in the affluent Glenora neighbourhood. Shortly after arriving, she wrote, she sat down with the couple in their living room and chatted casually about a recent trip to Nordegg. Then de Ruiter explained why they'd invited her. "For some years now, the calling has moved me to be with other women sexually, and now the calling is moving toward you," de Ruiter reportedly said. Over the next few hours, the woman asked several questions: how many others were there, and who were they? Why hadn't de Ruiter and Leigh Ann told the community this was happening? De Ruiter allegedly responded, "The world is not ready for this. People will not understand. I, John, will seem like a cliché."

The woman took a taxi home, spent several days mulling it over and ultimately refused the invitation. (She declined my interview request.) When she shared her experience online, de Ruiter's crisis-control machine rumbled to life. Over the course of two marathon meetings in March of 2017, de Ruiter dressed up his actions in metaphysical jargon. "To move sexually with another woman is to move in the same way that we will all move after we have died, not being confined to our relationships, to our marriage," he told hundreds of followers. College leadership encouraged members to trust that de Ruiter was operating with a pure heart, sending a mass email that said, "What comes from John has always been good." Later that month, de Ruiter's eldest son, Nicolas, wrote an extensive blog post acknowledging that, like many other followers, he'd struggled to accept his father's behaviour. But he eventually came to believe that de Ruiter and his teachings were "true and beautiful."

For other adherents, this was one scandal too many. After years of excusing his behaviour, disillusioned members began airing their fears and frustrations on a private Google forum called Birds of Being, a play on the de Ruiter–ism "bonds of being," a term he used to describe the connections he established with people via his unwavering gaze. And yet, for many followers, leaving was inconceivable. It would mean losing not only their mentor but their community—inside the group, members are discouraged from maintaining contact with defectors. Jasun Horsley, an ex-member who wrote a book about the organization called Dark Oasis, told me that de Ruiter's followers also feared supernatural retribution. "Some people, even if they've left, still haven't ceased to believe in John's mystical powers," he says. "If you believe he can astral project and all this other stuff, there's a different level of fear involved."

Horsley thinks of de Ruiter's diehards as lobsters in a pot, tolerating incrementally worsening behaviour. They are not fools, he says, but good-hearted people who have been gaslighted and brainwashed by a master manipulator. "Imagine a sort of enmeshment where you've let somebody into your psyche. That's destabilizing to turn away from," he says. "They believe John is God and therefore, anything he does, there must be an explanation for it. And they have to stay faithful."

***

De Ruiter's final downfall began not with another scandal, but a pandemic. In March of 2020, the group paused in-person meetings. It was the first time in years that many followers had spent significant time apart from de Ruiter. Instead of attending several meetings a week, they were stuck at home—no longer staring into his eyes, projecting meaning into his stilted monologues or watching zealots treat him like a god. With their newfound distance, some followers came to an alarming realization: they'd been under the spell of a controlling egomaniac.

COVID-19 caused event bookings to dry up as well, and in 2021, the College sold the Oasis Centre to the Aga Khan Foundation for $6.7 million and met over Zoom instead. According to a former member, it was during private video calls that women started sharing with each other different versions of a familiar story. These women declined or did not respond to my interview requests, and a publication ban prevents Maclean's from reporting details that could identify them. But, according to statements they later made to police, Leigh Ann would invite the women to meet de Ruiter at a specific time and place, most often in his home or another private location. When the women showed up, de Ruiter would explain that "the calling" was directing him toward them and that, by having sex with him, they would achieve a higher state of being.

The allegations date from 2012 to 2020, which means that some of the women waited a decade to make their report. This is not unusual. "The criminal route remains very difficult," says Merchasin, the lawyer who focuses on sexual misconduct in spiritual groups. "The system is so retraumatizing to survivors." In 2018, she investigated sexual-assault allegations against Sakyong Mipham Rinpoche, the leader of Shambhala, a worldwide Buddhist order based in Halifax. The allegations were found credible by an independent law firm, but police filed no charges. The following year, the Tibetan Buddhist teacher Surya Das was accused of telling pupils that meditating naked in his lap would further their spiritual training. No charges were laid against him either. And in the case of a supposed supernaturally powerful spiritual guru, women may have other reasons not to approach law enforcement. As Horsley put it to me, "They could start to feel like they're damned if they start to doubt the saviour."

Nonetheless, in early 2023, four of these women reported their experiences to Edmonton police. Emboldened by the first round of charges, an additional four women—three in June and one more in September—made allegations of their own.

The trial, which is expected to take place in late 2024 or early 2025, is among several current cases that may clarify how the concept of consent ought to be applied in the context of spiritual discipleships. In the summer of 2022, the Oakville megachurch pastor Bruxy Cavey was charged with sexual assault in relation to what he originally described as an affair with a parishioner. His accuser alleges he told her that, even though their behaviour was wrong, God would forgive them. A year later, the Native American actor Nathan Chasing Horse, known for his role in Dances With Wolves, was charged with sexual assault in B.C. and Alberta for his role leading a group called the Circle that allegedly preyed on young Indigenous women. He reportedly told at least one of his victims that the spirits of their ancestors were instructing him to have sex with them. (Both Chasing Horse and Cavey deny the allegations and intend to plead not guilty.)

Each of these cases is likely to revolve around the section of the Criminal Code that deals with consent—and, in particular, the clause that states that consent is legally invalid if "the accused induces the complainant to engage in the activity by abusing a position of trust, power or authority." This means that de Ruiter's convictions—whether or not he actually believed he was the living embodiment of truth or delivering enlightenment through sex—may be beside the point. "If a person rapes someone in a dark alley by force because 'God told him to do it,' it doesn't matter," says Merchasin. "We don't need to give any credence to whether he believed it or not. It's about the conduct, and a civil society can always govern conduct."

The prosecution will almost certainly argue that de Ruiter—a spiritual teacher, business owner and self-professed messiah—abused his position of power to obtain sex. The defence will likely try to paint a different picture: that the complainants were exercising their free will when they had sex with de Ruiter, a man desired by many. De Ruiter, of course, will continue to contend that he was only doing what he knew to be true. Ultimately, it will be up to a jury to decide whether or not his truth also constituted a criminal offence.

As de Ruiter awaits his day in court, he presides over a weary and dwindling flock. Following the charges, dozens of members, including some in his inner circle, left the group. In their absence, others have moved up to fill their spots. Joosse, who is now an associate professor of sociology at the University of Hong Kong, told me that this is standard after a scandal. "There's a shelf life to the tenure of these 'top people.' They often end up being disaffected or disavowed or leaving acrimoniously," says Joosse. "It's almost like the story is replaying itself." Horsley estimates the group has no more than 100 members left: de Ruiter's sons, former Oasis staffers and long-time members from around the world who still believe he is the messiah he says he is. "I certainly don't think him being prosecuted would cause them to distrust John because, well, it's like martyrdom," says Horsley.

Over the course of 2023, these followers, and de Ruiter himself, moved to the tiny town of Fort Assiniboine, about an hour and a half's drive northwest of Edmonton. They've bought homes there en masse, putting more than a few of the area's 200 residents on edge. The College's new gathering place is another couple of hours north, at an isolated campground called Midnight Sky, which the group purchased for $1 million in 2022.

De Ruiter and his remaining followers now hold meetings on the 120-acre property, where he has lately taken to warning about the apocalyptic dangers posed by aliens and rogue AI. Recently, his son Nicolas spoke to the group about another risk: the real possibility that his father could go to prison. If he does, there will no doubt be a small group of followers—the ones who have stuck with him for decades, through all the divorces and debacles—who will patiently await his release, eager for the opportunity to approach the mic and ask what new and profound truths he has discovered behind bars.


This article appears in the December 2023 print issue of Maclean's magazine. You can purchase the issue here, or become a Maclean's subscriber here.

 

https://macleans.ca/longforms/john-de-ruiter/

 

Nov 20, 2023

Exclusive Brethren told to 'create a crisis' to generate profits


The Post

Craig Hoyle

November 18, 2023

 

Leaked documents reveal how the pursuit of money is driving the secretive Exclusive Brethren, with one insider saying the sect has effectively become a “pyramid scheme”.

The religious group, which practices an extreme form of social isolation from wider society under its “doctrine of separation”, has an aggressive focus on maximising revenue from members and wider society, and current and former members said large sums of money were flowing upward towards world leader Bruce Hales.

The Sunday Star-Times can also reveal that incoming prime minister Christopher Luxon has had ongoing contact with senior Brethren since speaking at one of their seminars in 2016, and is not ruling out a similar appearance as prime minister.

The National Party has a chequered history with the Exclusive Brethren after the church tried to get the Don Brash-led National Party elected in 2005, and were outed for being behind pamphlets attacking the Greens.

At one of the latest international business conferences held in Sydney in September, Brethren members were told to have an “investor mindset” and given detailed instructions for how to generate profits, including taking financial advantage of crises.

Brethren leaders took that instruction a step further, telling attendees: “We may need to create a crisis.”

Exclusive Brethren offer financial advice

A business conference in Auckland this week had a very special guest speaker - the brother of the worldwide leader of the Exclusive Brethren church.

Academics and former members who reviewed notes from the seminar were particularly concerned by that suggestion.

“It’s just a massive red flag,” said Sara Rahmani, a lecturer in religious studies at Victoria University’s School of Social and Cultural Studies.

The seminar was organised by Universal Business Team (UBT), a Sydney-registered company that describes itself as a “global consultancy group” providing “services and advice” to about 3000 Brethren-owned businesses in 19 countries, with a combined revenue of more than NZ$12.6 billion.

In a written response, a spokesperson for the Exclusive Brethren, who have rebranded themselves as the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church (PBCC), said statements made at the seminar “were presentations to members of the church, not from it” – however a review by the Star-Times found speakers were senior members of the church, including relatives of Hales.

 

UBT holds regular seminars for Brethren members, and the Star-Times previously reported on a 2016 event held at Vector Arena where guest speakers included then All Blacks coach Steve Hansen, Victoria Cross winner Willie Apiata, and then Air NZ chief executive Christopher Luxon - who is now in coalition talks to become Aotearoa’s next prime minister.

A spokesperson for Luxon said UBT “was a longstanding corporate customer of Air NZ”, and he spoke about leadership and the national carrier’s business strategy in his 2016 address. He was not paid for his appearance.

Luxon stood by his decision to speak at the Brethren conference, the spokesperson said, “and he possibly would do so again”.

In response to a question about whether Luxon has had subsequent contact with the Brethren, its members or subsidiary organisations, the spokesperson said he maintained relationships “with many people from his Air NZ days”.

“Since entering politics, he has occasionally met [senior Brethren leader] Caleb Hall, the UBT CEO who he knew from his Air NZ days, for coffee.”

 

UBT, which Luxon’s spokesperson described as a “large and successful small business network”, funnels profits back to various Brethren causes as charitable donations, with large sums of money flowing between sect halls, education trusts and the sect’s National Assistance Fund.

Membership of UBT is theoretically voluntary for Brethren business owners, but Peter Hart, who was excommunicated in 2020 for questioning the leadership of Hales, said in reality that was not the case.

“[As a small business owner] people put pressure on me to be part of UBT, and I said ‘oh, I thought it was optional?’ And they said ‘yes, it’s optional, but you should be doing it’.”

Most Brethren business owners took the easy route and went along with UBT membership, Hart said, resulting in an enormous flow of cash to the organisation.

 

“It was morally wrong to me that you should have that pressure put on you to join a business group as part of your church.”

Beginning around 2010, UBT undertook a review of all Brethren-owned companies worldwide, grading them into a traffic light system: green for good, orange for those needing work, and red for those that should be ditched immediately.

Hart’s company, which was struggling at the time, was graded red, and he was ordered “to close the business down and work for other Brethren”.

“All the red cases got sent to Bruce Hales to look at, and that was his advice.”

 

Hart ultimately declined to sell his medical products business, managing to slow the process down enough until revenue picked up - no thanks, he said, to UBT and Hales: “It was very poor advice that they gave me.”

The Sydney seminar notes make repeated references to Hales and his predecessors, including his father, directing members to obey his instructions.

“They are doing the thinking for us and we just need to do the doing,” reads one reference to the so-called Great Men. Another reads: “The key is to always follow, don’t be independent and think I know better.”

Rahmani, the religious studies lecturer, who reviewed the notes, said the overall messaging appeared to be about consolidating control and “maintaining legitimacy”.

 

“Linguistically, they elevate these Great Men’s position and sainthood by drawing parallels between them and God, and then them and Jesus … The central theme is obedience.”

Michael Lee, an associate professor of marketing at Auckland University, explained that a strong emphasis on business was a common theme among conservative religious groups.

“That’s the one area that they can comfortably educate their members in, and do well in,” he said. “But the business focus gets a bit disturbing when it’s ‘we should create crises for the benefit of others’.”

Lee, who also reviewed the seminar papers, said some of the advice was “pretty good”, such as promoting the importance of healthcare and having an abundance mindset, although the patriarchal language throughout “wouldn’t normally fly in this day and age for mainstream companies”.

 

Lindy Jacomb, a former Brethren member who founded the Olive Leaf Network to help people escape high-demand religious groups, said the Exclusive Brethren emphasis on profit had been turbocharged under Hales.

“Prosperity gospel theology teaches that personal and financial wellbeing is the highest sign of God’s favour, and God’s favour is seen primarily through financial prosperity,” said Jacomb, who is now trained as a Baptist pastor.

“It does seem like the Brethren are increasingly teaching this kind of vision of life.”

The leaked seminar notes lay out a focus on health and wealth, with members told to care for their physical wellbeing for the sake of profit.

“We need to be as healthy as possible to be a good employee,” read the notes, which were distributed widely within the Brethren community.

Rahmani said it was concerning when groups equated physical health with morality, “suggesting that people who are sick are sinners, and therefore deserving”.

SUPPLIED

A diagram from the UBT seminar in September shows how the Brethren are focusing on multiple aspects of members' lives.

The sect is even more assertive in extracting money from regular society. “Take it from them because it doesn’t belong to them anyway,” said Hart, recounting the Brethren attitude toward non-members. “They can be quite ruthless.”

Hales has previously told members to have “an utter hatred of the world”. Lee, the associate professor of marketing, said fostering a position of “us against the world” was a recognisable business practice.

“When Apple was a very niche product, that was their selling idea - us, the special, the unique, those who know better, the enlightened ones, versus the masses … They feel like they’re part of this group that is persecuted or special, and if they were to leave, they’re leaving behind their band of brothers.”

The September seminar notes include common business terms such as “whale hunting”, which refers to the practice of targeting high-value potential customers. Attendees were also told they should “understand why we won when Covid hit” - an apparent reference to the billions scooped up by Brethren-run companies in lucrative PPE contracts with the UK government at the beginning of the pandemic.

Brethren business owners who become wealthy are often elevated to positions of leadership within the sect, with Jacomb saying it appeared material success had become more important than “spiritual depth of understanding”.

“It’s really concerning if people can reach positions of spiritual leadership due to their financial status,” she said.

 

The Brethren are scrupulous about keeping as much money as possible circulating within their own community. Recently, members were surveyed worldwide about their property holdings and mortgages - the results showed that Brethren held about US$13.2b (NZ$22.1b) in private property assets, and owed US$4b (NZ$6.7b) in mortgage debt.

Subsequent teachings at an October conference called Strive 2024 – held across three continents in Sydney, Australia; Birmingham, UK; and Westfield, New Jersey - suggested the Brethren needed to take a “creative approach”, with a proposal that richer members buy equity in the homes of those with mortgages to “free them from the bank”.

Members are also being encouraged to sign up for the Personal Prosperity Plan (PPP) - a newly-released wealth management system “adding structure and a plan into our affairs”, with financial control extending from the business realm into personal lives.

The plan is available for “every willing individual globally”, and pushed as a “massive win” for Brethren businesses. Leaked notes from Strive 2024, which was attended by hundreds of New Zealand Brethren, suggested each Brethren student should be signed up for a PPP by the time they left school.

In a statement provided to the Star-Times, a spokesperson for UBT said the PPPs were “aimed at enabling business owners to care for their employees in a meaningful and long-lasting way by encouraging them to be aware about their finances, caring for themselves and caring for others”.

“Obviously, it is up to employers and employees if this is taken up.”

In their written statements, neither the PBCC nor UBT responded to a question about how members were expected to balance personal choice against the sect’s instructions to follow leaders’ orders. A current member of the Brethren said there was a clear feeling that “those who reject it will be left behind”.

Jacomb said the growing financial web was “undoubtedly making it much harder for members to leave”.

“You can’t be employed outside of the Brethren ecosystem, which was and still is a barrier, but now there are all these other financial areas of your life tied in - your mortgage, your insurance, your superannuation - that add layers of complexity to extracting yourself.”

And there are signs that not all members are happy with being encircled financially. A source told the Star-Times that when the mortgage survey was distributed the return rate was 89% - meaning one in 10 members did not comply.

“I think there would be a number of people who are really uncomfortable with the direction that things are taking under Bruce Hales’s leadership,” said Jacomb, adding that non-compliance by some members was “a really bold step”.

“We know that they will be being closely watched.”

 

Craig Hoyle is a former member of the Exclusive Brethren. His book, Excommunicated: A multigenerational story of leaving the Exclusive Brethren, published by HarperCollins, is available now. RRP $39.99.

 

https://www.thepost.co.nz/a/nz-news/350113380/exclusive-brethren-told-create-crisis-generate-profits