Investigators and prosecutors criticised after trial of 11 members of church and two affiliated bodies that could have led to ban
The Guardian
Agence France Presse in Brussels
March 11, 2016
A court in Brussels has thrown out charges that could have seen Church of Scientology banned as a “criminal enterprise” in Belgium, after a judge said the defendants were targeted because of their religion.
Eleven members of the celebrity-backed, US-based church and two affiliated bodies had been charged with fraud, extortion, the illegal practice of medicine, running a criminal enterprise and violating the right to privacy.
“The entire proceedings are declared inadmissible for a serious and irremediable breach of the right to a fair trial,” the presiding judge, Yves Regimont, said on Friday.
He criticised the investigators involved in an 18-year inquiry into Scientology in Belgium for what he said was prejudice, and prosecutors for being vague in their case against the religion.
“The defendants were prosecuted primarily because they were Scientologists,” Regimont added.
The case was the subject of a seven-week trial that ended last December.
“It’s a relief,” Scientology’s spokesman in Belgium, Eric Roux, told reporters outside the court. “When you have had 20 years of your life under a pressure that you know is unfair, where one attacks your beliefs and not something you have done, the day when the court says it officially, it’s a big relief,.”
Defence lawyer Pascal Vanderveeren denounced the case as careless and prejudiced, adding that it was aimed at “attacking Scientology and not those who are part of it”.
Marie Abadi, a former Scientology member who has become a strong opponent of it, said she expected an appeal, adding: “We are evidently very disappointed. Either the facts are too old, or not precise enough. We are certain the prosecutor will appeal because things must budge.”
Championed by famous members such as Hollywood actors Tom Cruise and John Travolta, Scientology stirs up sharp divisions. Critics decry it as a cult and a scam, while supporters say it offers much-needed spiritual support in a fast-changing world.
Prosecutors had asked for the court to completely dissolve the Belgian branch of Scientology and the affiliated European Bureau for Human Rights, and for them to face a fine.
The defence team said the charges were nothing more than an attempt to blacken Scientology’s reputation.
The Belgian authorities launched a first investigation in 1997 after several former members complained about the church’s practices.
A second investigation followed in 2008 when an employment agency charged that the church had made bogus job offers so as to draw in and recruit new members.
Headquartered in Los Angeles, the Church of Scientology was founded in 1954 by science fiction writer L Ron Hubbard. It is recognised as a religion in the US and in other countries such as Italy, Spain, the Netherlands and Sweden, and claims a worldwide membership of 12 million.
But it has come under repeated scrutiny by authorities in several European countries, particularly in Germany. Several German regions have considered banning Scientology, while Berlin initially banned the cast of the Cruise Nazi-era movie Valkyrie from filming at historical locations but later relented.
A court in Spain in 2007 annulled a decision by the Spanish justice ministry to sremove it from the country’s register of officially recognised religions.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/11/scientology-criminal-enterprise-case-thrown-out-belgian-judge
The Guardian
Agence France Presse in Brussels
March 11, 2016
Eleven members of the celebrity-backed, US-based church and two affiliated bodies had been charged with fraud, extortion, the illegal practice of medicine, running a criminal enterprise and violating the right to privacy.
“The entire proceedings are declared inadmissible for a serious and irremediable breach of the right to a fair trial,” the presiding judge, Yves Regimont, said on Friday.
He criticised the investigators involved in an 18-year inquiry into Scientology in Belgium for what he said was prejudice, and prosecutors for being vague in their case against the religion.
“The defendants were prosecuted primarily because they were Scientologists,” Regimont added.
The case was the subject of a seven-week trial that ended last December.
“It’s a relief,” Scientology’s spokesman in Belgium, Eric Roux, told reporters outside the court. “When you have had 20 years of your life under a pressure that you know is unfair, where one attacks your beliefs and not something you have done, the day when the court says it officially, it’s a big relief,.”
Defence lawyer Pascal Vanderveeren denounced the case as careless and prejudiced, adding that it was aimed at “attacking Scientology and not those who are part of it”.
Marie Abadi, a former Scientology member who has become a strong opponent of it, said she expected an appeal, adding: “We are evidently very disappointed. Either the facts are too old, or not precise enough. We are certain the prosecutor will appeal because things must budge.”
Championed by famous members such as Hollywood actors Tom Cruise and John Travolta, Scientology stirs up sharp divisions. Critics decry it as a cult and a scam, while supporters say it offers much-needed spiritual support in a fast-changing world.
Prosecutors had asked for the court to completely dissolve the Belgian branch of Scientology and the affiliated European Bureau for Human Rights, and for them to face a fine.
The defence team said the charges were nothing more than an attempt to blacken Scientology’s reputation.
The Belgian authorities launched a first investigation in 1997 after several former members complained about the church’s practices.
A second investigation followed in 2008 when an employment agency charged that the church had made bogus job offers so as to draw in and recruit new members.
Headquartered in Los Angeles, the Church of Scientology was founded in 1954 by science fiction writer L Ron Hubbard. It is recognised as a religion in the US and in other countries such as Italy, Spain, the Netherlands and Sweden, and claims a worldwide membership of 12 million.
But it has come under repeated scrutiny by authorities in several European countries, particularly in Germany. Several German regions have considered banning Scientology, while Berlin initially banned the cast of the Cruise Nazi-era movie Valkyrie from filming at historical locations but later relented.
A court in Spain in 2007 annulled a decision by the Spanish justice ministry to sremove it from the country’s register of officially recognised religions.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/11/scientology-criminal-enterprise-case-thrown-out-belgian-judge
No comments:
Post a Comment