Showing posts with label Homeschooling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Homeschooling. Show all posts

Dec 16, 2020

French ban on homeschooling targets Islamist extremism

French ban on homeschooling targets Islamist extremism
CHRIS BREMMER
THE TIMES
DECEMBER 7, 2020

Homeschooling will be banned for all children in France from the age of three as President Emmanuel Macron presses ahead with plans to clamp down on radical Islam.

Interior Minister Gerald Darmanin, a hardline conservative who Mr Macron appointed in July to head his security push, said the aim was to save “these children who are outside the scope of the republic”. He was referring to the several thousand children, and ­especially girls, who are educated at home by fundamentalist families and disappear off the radar of the education system.

About 50,000 children receive home education in France out of 12 million pupils.

A draft law to curb the spread of a radical “separatist” culture in France’s big Muslim population will receive cabinet endorsement this week. However, the homeschooling ban may be struck out of the law as unconstitutional when it is examined by the state Constitutional Council, the government has been warned.

All children in France will have to attend recognised schools once they turn three and will be recorded with individual identification numbers in the education system.

The so-called “law to strengthen republican principles”, drafted over the past two years, is the main plank in Mr Macron’s offensive to curb the hardline Islamist doctrines that foster what he calls a “separatist” mentality and feed terrorism. The bill has been given extra impetus by three terrorist ­attacks since late September in which four people were knifed to death, including Samuel Paty, a Parisian school teacher who was beheaded after he showed pupils caricatures of Muhammad.

The anti-separatism law has been prefaced by a police crackdown on 76 mosques and prayer groups, out of 2600 in France. Several have been closed and foreign imams expelled.

Under the new rules, Muslim leaders will be required to sign a commitment to French “republican” values, including equality between the sexes and the exclusion of religion from public life. The signatories must “refuse all political Islam and all foreign interference”, the Elysee Palace said.

Foreign financing of the faith will be ended and foreign imams will be phased out and replaced with French-trained prayer leaders. Mosques and prayer halls will come under close scrutiny and state officials will be given power to override decisions by town mayors that breach France’s strict exclusion of religion from public life. These include such things as women-only hours in swimming pools and sports centres.

Mr Macron’s team wants the state apparatus to flush out ­extremists, who they say are ­poisoning the minds of the disaffected young in the poor non-white towns that ring the big cities.

“We are using the Al Capone method,” a presidential aide told the Journal du Dimanche, referring to the way the FBI brought down the gangster by prosecuting him over tax evasion. “We are looking at the radicals’ environment, where they work, where they pray, where their children go to school, what restaurants they use.”

The anti-radical clampdown has been accepted without criticism by the established Muslim authorities, including the French Council of the Muslim Faith and the Paris Grand Mosque.

Mar 7, 2020

Doomsday preppers put faith in God and plan for the end of all things

Tracy Simmons
Religion News Service
March 5, 2020

(RNS) — Twenty years ago mass panic swept the globe as 1999 came to a close and programmers scrambled to fix faulty technology that some presumed would send society into disarray at the strike of midnight.

Some believed “Y2K” would be doomsday.

But when the new millennium began, networks — and daily life — continued as normal.

Survivalist author Jim, Rawles — who lives off grid somewhere in the Pacific Northwest and who prefers to separate his given name and his family name with a comma — said the frenzy was a good thing.

If it weren’t for the hype, he said, tech companies wouldn’t have put the time and resources into remediating the computer codes, and the effect would have been catastrophic for the banking systems.

Two decades later Rawles is helping people, mostly Christians, prepare for whatever could be the next disaster heading toward civilization.

His website, SurvivalBlog.com, has 100,000 regular visitors.

“It’s common sense,” he said. “The government has proven itself time and again woefully inadequate when it comes to disaster relief. You can’t depend on the government. You’re on your own.”

He said it’s up to heads of families to find a way to provide.

Rawles lives with his wife in a lightly populated area in the Inland Northwest, where they home-school their children, grow their own food, raise livestock, hunt and fish. He wouldn’t say where they live, and he uses a Georgia phone number so as to not give any hints.

As part of the American Redoubt movement, he advocates for others to do the same. Not just for family preparedness, but also for political reasons.

American Redoubt, he explained, is a migration movement that encourages like-minded people to relocate to the Inland Northwest so they can be in a geographically safe area and make that area more conservative.

For example, he explained, the Palouse — a pastoral region in southeastern Washington and northern Idaho — has miles of pea, wheat and lentil fields with hydroelectric dams nearby. It’s also generally free of natural disasters, like hurricanes and earthquakes.

“The other goal is to take an already conservative Christian area and make it more conservative by encouraging conservatives coast to coast to move here,” he said, “to make a red state a deeper shade of red.”

The Redoubt movement is growing, but because many choose to live off grid, it’s hard to know just how much.

“Conservative Christian families tend to have large families, so demographically we’ve already won the war. If liberals moving here have 1.8 children and we have 3.5, we win,” he said.

His forthcoming book, “The Ultimate Preppers Survival Guide,” explains “how to survive in the short term as society begins to collapse, and how to thrive in the long term.”

Rawles said those who can’t afford to move out of a big city can still prepare by storing a minimum of four months of food and, most importantly, keeping a water filter on hand.

And although Rawles does believe collapse of society is near, he doesn’t wade into Armageddon prophecy — though many preppers do.

However, he does believe we are living closer to the end times than ever, “and we need to be prepared spiritually and physically.”



A map of the American Redoubt region of the northwest United States. Map courtesy of Creative Commons

He said there are economic concerns, like a potential recession, that will drive more people to the Redoubt. And with the new coronavirus outbreak, more people are likely to move away from populous cities and join, he said.

“I think it’s cause for considerable concern,” Rawles said. “I think it has the potential to sweep the planet.”

In recent years, controversial televangelist Jim Bakker has focused on faith-based survivalism, selling a host of products meant to help believers survive the end times, including packs of 24 buckets, each with 90 meals, for $3,000.

Fears of the end times were also cited in a recent missing-children case in Idaho.

Matthew Sutton, Edward R. Meyer Distinguished Professor at Washington State University and author of “American Apocalypse: A History of Modern Evangelicalism,” said apocalyptic sensibility has helped fuel the evangelical movement in the U.S.

“It you look at the world and you see chaos and despair and death and destruction, it allows you to make sense of that. It gives meaning. It gives purpose,” he said.

And, he added, it creates a sense of urgency.

“Good religious liberals might be working to build the kingdom of God on earth, but they know they’ve got hundreds of thousands of years to do it. So they’re eager to do good, but don’t have this sense that the clock is ticking,” Sutton said, “Whereas apocalyptic-thinking evangelicals recognize that they have to act, and they have to act fast, and they have to act now because Jesus is right around the corner.”

He said this mindset spikes when there are global problems, potentially like the coronavirus outbreak.

Pastor Charles Baldwin of Liberty Fellowship in Kalispell, Montana, is a proponent of people moving away from big cities and to “freedomist areas of the country,” but he said panic shouldn’t be the reason.

“Hysteria feeds into the fear factor, which makes people less reasonable and more willing to accept government protection,” he said. “People under normal circumstances would never surrender to government, but in panic mode look to the government to come save us.”

Baldwin, who ran for president in 2008, moved from Florida to Montana in 2010 with his wife and extended family after years of prayer and discernment, he said.

His family doesn’t live off the grid, but his home is self-contained with its own water supply, he said.

The purpose of the move, he explained, was to live under God’s law and not man’s.

“When a city or government is not allowing you to live free, find a place that will let you live free. I think that message is attractive to Christians and non-Christians,” he said. “People want to be away from the rat race, the big metro areas, and move to a more family friendly community. They want to be someplace they know they won’t be persecuted for having a gun in their truck, or because they like to keep to themself. It’s more of a live and let live mentality.”

American Redoubt, Baldwin said, is more of a freedomist movement than a Christian movement. But the Bible is filled with examples of God protecting his people by leading them to new places, he said.

More concerning than the new coronavirus, he said, is the possibility of nuclear exchange. Rural America is the safest place to be when, or if, that happens.

However, Baldwin said, relocating is a big decision and shouldn’t be taken lightly.

“You have to know what you’re doing and why you’re doing it,” he said.

https://religionnews.com/2020/03/05/religious-preppers-put-faith-in-god-and-plan-for-the-end-of-all-things/

Feb 26, 2020

CultNEWS101 Articles: 2/26/2020




Twelve Tribes, Legion of Christ, La Luz Del Mundo, Polygamy, Hasidic, Home  Schooling, Religious Freedom, YouTube, Jehovah's Witnesses

"The headquarters of the Sydney-based arm of the Twelve Tribes cult was raided [February 18th] by detectives as a part of Strike Force Nanegai.

A Current Affair can reveal that police have been investigating the cult known for its strict disciplining of children and lack of medical care since 2018.

Detectives from Springwood Police searched the cult's Peppercorn Creek Farm property in Picton for six hours earlier today, collecting documents and diary entries as evidence.

Numerous investigations into the Twelve Tribes have taken place overseas within the last decade, including a US investigation into allegations of the group forcing their young members to work on farms and factory assembly lines, and a German police investigation into the repeated physical punishment of children.

A Current Affair has heard numerous accounts of Australian children of the Twelve Tribes being beaten with rods from a very young age."
"The cardinal's response was not what Yolanda Martínez had expected — or could abide.

Her son had been sexually abused by a priest of the Legion of Christ, a disgraced religious order. And now she was calling Cardinal Valasio De Paolis -- the Vatican official appointed by the pope to lead the Legion and to clean it up -- to report the settlement the group was offering, and to express her outrage.

The terms: Martínez's family would receive 15,000 euros ($16,300) from the order. But in return, her son would have to recant the testimony he gave to Milan prosecutors that the priest had repeatedly assaulted him when he was a 12-year-old student at the order's youth seminary in northern Italy. He would have to lie.

The cardinal did not seem shocked. He did not share her indignation."
RNS:  La Luz del Mundo minister says abuse allegations are false

"A minister for La Luz Del Mundo, a Mexico-based Pentecostal movement that claims 5 million members, said new allegations of abuse against more than a dozen of its leaders are false and meant to disrespect their sacred celebration this week.
"We find these accusations to be absolutely untrue and ridiculous," said Jack Freeman, a spokesman and minister for La Luz Del Mundo. "There is no possible way that those could have taken place."
At a news conference Friday (Feb. 14), church leaders gathered at the Fairplex in Pomona to address the allegations made in a recently filed lawsuit against the church and its leaders. The media briefing took place as church members flocked to the fairgrounds for the third and final day of the Holy Supper, a sacred rite that church members say memorializes the death and salvation of Jesus Christ."  



Salt Lake Tribune: Lindsay Hansen Park: It helps no one to equate polygamy with slavery

"In the late 19th century, thousands of human hands were systematically amputated from enslaved Africans who failed to meet quotas for extracting rubber in the Congo. Nearly three decades after the United States abolished the practice of slavery, rubber was bought and sold to feed a growing demand in the international tire market created by Dunlop and the Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co.

This is just one small glimpse into the brutal history of the transatlantic slave trade that robbed the personhood and freedom of millions. Millions more were tortured for centuries while black and brown bodies were systematically purchased, exploited, raped and brutalized in state-sanctioned violence. The consequences of this system still deeply impact our world today.

This is likely why comments by anti-polygamy activist Angela Kelly raised concerns at a caucus lunch this week as she advocated to vote against Senate Bill 102, which reduces bigamy among consenting adults to an infraction.

Kelly, a white woman and director of Sound Choices Coalition (a group that seeks to criminalize polygamy), used her invitation to speak with the Utah Legislature's House Minority Caucus to draw comparisons between Mormon polygamy and slavery. Taking her comparison a step further, she singled out Rep. Sandra Hollins, the only black legislator in Utah, by handing her a name tag that read "Slave" and verbally referenced Hollins' black skin.

The act drew public outrage for good reason. Not only are Kelly's words racist and aggressive, they are concerning coming from someone claiming to advocate for the marginalized.

Polygamy is not slavery. Polygamy is its own system with its own unique challenges and we needn't plunder the traumas of the trans-Atlantic slave trade to highlight those issues.There are plenty that stand on their own.

To effect change and disrupt power structures, we need a working knowledge of how those structures interact. Kelly's remarks reflect a privilege that lacks important historical distinctions. This context is critical to helping victims and survivors from these communities get the justice they deserve.

My work allows me unique and exclusive access to some of the most isolated fundamentalist polygamous groups in the American West. As a born-and-raised LDS monogamist, feminist activist and researcher on the history of polygamy, I have struggled to accept some of the nuances that challenged my preconceived notions about these communities.

Polygamy is hard. I still don't like it. It systematically discriminates based on gender. It commodifies women. I've seen true horrors as the result of this doctrine."
CBC News: Hasidic schools aim to strike a balance between faith and provincial curriculum, court hears

"Quebec's Hasidic community is trying to strike a balance between preserving its own religious faith and satisfying the educational requirements of the provincial government, the president of Quebec's Jewish Association for Homeschooling told a Montreal courtroom [February 17, 2020].

Abraham Ekstein was the final witness in the civil case brought before the Quebec Superior Court by Yohanan and Shifra Lowen, two former Hasidic Jews who say the province and their home community of Tash should have done more to provide them with a secular education.

"We strive to maintain our culture, to transmit our culture to our children, to survive as a people," said Ekstein, a Hasidic Jew and father of seven who lives in Montreal's Outremont borough.

"This whole case is so sad for us, in the sense that there are no winners."

The Lowens are seeking a declaratory judgment from Justice Martin Castonguay, to compel the province to do more to ensure children in Tash are taught subjects like math, English and French.

Castonguay will also need to consider whether new rules for home-schooling put in place by the previous Liberal government and strengthened under the Coalition Avenir Québec have helped achieve that goal."

" ... As president of the home-schooling association, however, Ekstein said he met multiple times with Tash leaders in recent years and that they are aware of the need to work with the province.

He acknowledged there had been resistance in Tash, which was founded in 1962, over fears the province was trying to "impose assimilation."

However, he said, "I'm convinced that we are going in the right direction and that children will succeed much better."

Children in Tash were the subject of an investigation by Quebec's youth protection agency beginning in 2014, the court heard last week.

The agency found that boys were taught "little to nothing" from the provincial curriculum, while the girls received a balance between a religious and a secular education — learning math, social sciences and English."

CultNews101: YouTube Channel
News, links and resources about cults, cultic groups, abusive relationships, movements, religions, political organizations and related topics.

Goatlike Personality: Watchtower lost in the Netherlands.




News, Education, Intervention, Recovery


Intervention101.com to help families and friends understand and effectively respond to the complexity of a loved one's cult involvement.
CultRecovery101.com assists group members and their families make the sometimes difficult transition from coercion to renewed individual choice.
CultNEWS101.com news, links, resources.
Cults101.org resources about cults, cultic groups, abusive relationships, movements, religions, political organizations and related topics.

Selection of articles for CultNEWS101 does not mean that Patrick Ryan or Joseph Kelly agree with the content. We provide information from many points of view in order to promote dialogue.

Feb 18, 2020

Hasidic schools aim to strike a balance between faith and provincial curriculum, court hears

Abraham Ekstein, president of the Quebec Jewish Association for Homeschooling, testified Monday at the civil trial brought against the government and the Hasidic community of Tash by former members of the Hasidic community, Yohanan and Shifra Lowen. (Benjamin Shingler/CBC)
'I'm convinced that we are going in the right direction,' president of home-schooling association says

Benjamin Shingler
CBC News
Februay 17, 2020

Quebec's Hasidic community is trying to strike a balance between preserving its own religious faith and satisfying the educational requirements of the provincial government, the president of Quebec's Jewish Association for Homeschooling told a Montreal courtroom Monday.

Abraham Ekstein was the final witness in the civil case brought before the Quebec Superior Court by Yohanan and Shifra Lowen, two former Hasidic Jews who say the province and their home community of Tash should have done more to provide them with a secular education.

"We strive to maintain our culture, to transmit our culture to our children, to survive as a people," said Ekstein, a Hasidic Jew and father of seven who lives in Montreal's Outremont borough.

"This whole case is so sad for us, in the sense that there are no winners."

The Lowens are seeking a declaratory judgment from Justice Martin Castonguay, to compel the province to do more to ensure children in Tash are taught subjects like math, English and French.

Castonguay will also need to consider whether new rules for home-schooling put in place by the previous Liberal government and strengthened under the Coalition Avenir Québec have helped achieve that goal.

Ekstein was the sole witness called by David Bannon, the lawyer defending schools in Tash, a Hasidic enclave in the suburb of Boisbriand, north of Montreal.

Castonguay had Ekstein leave the courtroom several times during his testimony, to allow debate between lawyers over the relevance of some of what he had said, given that Ekstein doesn't live in Tash and isn't directly involved in schooling in that community. 


Fears of assimilation


As president of the home-schooling association, however, Ekstein said he met multiple times with Tash leaders in recent years and that they are aware of the need to work with the province.

He acknowledged there had been resistance in Tash, which was founded in 1962, over fears the province was trying to "impose assimilation."

However, he said, "I'm convinced that we are going in the right direction and that children will succeed much better."

Children in Tash were the subject of an investigation by Quebec's youth protection agency beginning in 2014, the court heard last week.

The agency found that boys were taught "little to nothing" from the provincial curriculum, while the girls received a balance between a religious and a secular education — learning math, social sciences and English.

Youth protection official Marie-Josée Bernier testified that about 280 of the 320 boys who were assessed were flagged for further monitoring, given their poor level of English and math skills.

The new rules adopted in 2017 led to improved collaboration with the local English school board, the court heard, and after that, fewer than than 100 boys were flagged for further monitoring.

A solid foundation?


Yohanan Lowen testified last week he had spent long days at the school in Tash, rising before 6 a.m. and studying the Jewish scriptures from that time until past 9 p.m. — except on the Sabbath.

When he left the community, he said, he couldn't speak French or English and had no understanding of subjects like math and science.

Ekstein wasn't able to say to what extent education at the religious schools in Tash had changed in recent years.

In a document submitted to the court, an investigator hired by the plaintiffs said the last students left the boys' school in Tash shortly before 9:30 p.m. this Sunday.

While Ekstein said he believed the provincial curriculum was worthwhile, he also argued religious education given to boys laid a solid foundation for the future.

"A child who finishes this rigorous Talmudic education — nothing stands in his way to achieve anything else in his life," said Ekstein, now 41 and on the verge of becoming a chartered accountant.

Closing arguments in the trial are scheduled for Wednesday. A judgment isn't expected for several months.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Benjamin Shingler
Journalist

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/quebec-tash-hasidic-lowen-defence-1.5466399

Mar 3, 2018

Illegal ‘schools’ teach children hatred

● Extremist books preach homophobia
● Experts demand change to home education laws


Nicola Woolcock, Education Correspondent
Neil JohnstonThe Times
March 3, 2018


Religious extremists are exploiting lax home education laws to expose children to hate-filled material at scores of unregistered "schools" and secret teaching groups.

Extremist texts seized from illegal schools allege that homosexuality is an "abomination", that sodomy is punishable by death and that a wife cannot "refuse sexual intercourse without sound reason".

Boys and girls could marry once they reached puberty, one document seen by The Times states. It also blames rapes on the way women dress, saying: "If a sweet thing is left uncovered, swarms of dirty creatures are liable to prey upon it and corrupt it."

At least 350 unregistered schools have been set up across Britain, according to Ofsted, the education regulator. Experts say they have been fuelled by a surge in home-educated children whose number has risen by almost 50 per cent in five years to at least 33,000.

While these schools can technically be inspected by Ofsted, at least 80 smaller "teaching groups" have been set up, often in warehouses and above shops, and are outside its control.

"I have huge concerns about unregistered schools and the lack of regulation and inspection," Robert Halfon, head of the Commons education committee, told The Times. "Any school of any kind shouldn't be unregistered. There shouldn't be room for grey areas. Even if they have less than five pupils and are open less than 18 hours they should be inspected and registered."

Mr Halfon, a former education minister, said he was supportive of parents who choose to teach their children outside school but his remarks will inflame thousands of responsible home educators who fiercely guard their independence. Children are home-schooled for an array of reasons and most are thought to be receiving an adequate standard of education.

Ofsted has issued warning notices to 50 suspected unregistered schools, 38 have closed or ceased to operate illegally and 12 are under criminal investigation. However, more than two years after Nicky Morgan, then education secretary, ordered the prosecution of the founders of 18 illegal schools, no case has reached court. Sources at Ofsted suggested evidence had been passed on but no action had been taken by prosecutors. Ofsted has spoken of frustration at its limited powers.

The Times obtained five extremist books relating to Islam, including Dos and Do Nots of Islam and The Islam Way of Life. One was by Abu Ameenah Bilal Philips, a Jamaican-born extremist Muslim preacher who has been banned from Britain. Concerns have also been raised about illegal Christian and Jewish schools.

Izzy Posen, 23, who went to "ultra-orthodox" illegal Jewish schools in Stamford Hill, north London, from the age of seven, said that he was not taught English until 13. "They have a suspicious view of secular subjects and besides the lack of education, hygiene levels were atrocious," he said. "There was corporal punishment, no methods were off the table but it was usually a big wooden ladle."

Last week a teacher was filmed appearing to strike a boy at an unregistered ultra- orthodox Jewish school in Westcliff-on-Sea, in Essex.

Amanda Spielman, chief inspector at Ofsted, has warned that religious hardliners were exploiting homeschooling rules. "If people choose to educate their children at home once upon a time it would have been the Brighton and Totnes brigades doing their homespun thing, but we are seeing the emergence of things that nobody ever contemplated," she said.

Edward Hardy's daughter starred in the musical Matilda but has never been to school. He attacked Mr Halfon's proposals, saying: "The notion that children in school are safe is a delusion — whether it's abuse from bullies, teachers or in the home. This assumption that you need to keep closer tabs on everybody creates a feeling of mistrust."

Illegal schools have been found in Birmingham, Luton and London boroughs. About a quarter are faith-based. In November 2015 the government proposed to tighten the regulation of out-of-school education settings, but this was shelved after being opposed by the Church of England. Now the Labour peer, Lord Soley, is attempting to introduce a private members' bill to strengthen local authority powers.

The Department for Education said it and Ofsted agreed on cases to send to the Crown Prosecution Service: "If the director of public prosecutions takes a decision to charge, the case comes to the secretary of state for his consent. So far no cases have reached that stage."

Lessons for children
"It is lawful to give slight punishment to the wife for her adverse behaviour but it is not permissible to beat her black and blue."

"If a sweet thing is left uncovered, swarms of dirty creatures are liable to prey upon it and corrupt it. Similar is the case of a woman. The current wave of rape incidents in regions where public exposure of women prevails, strengthens this argument beyond doubt."

"Celibacy is an unlawful criminal indulgence in sinful violations involving sex. Socially it is a disruptive and destructive act amounting to disobedience to Allah."

"Homosexuality is not only an abomination but also unbecoming to human dignity."

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/news/children-taught-hatred-at-illegal-schools-as-experts-demand-change-to-home-education-laws-glmj7ps03

Feb 3, 2018

'I broke away from a strict homeschooling community cult'

'Judy' studied hard and managed to go overseas to carry out missionary work
BBC News
February 2, 2018

When you're very young, your parents or guardians are responsible for nurturing and teaching you as you grow up, but how do you know if you are getting a good upbringing?

The news that a teenager escaped from her home in California, where she and her 12 siblings were held in shackles by their parents, sent shockwaves across the world.

But what happens to children who are brought up under such restricted conditions?

Judy (not her real name) told the BBC about what life was like for her living in a "homeschool community" in Oregon, USA.

'His word was law'


"I was raised in a homeschool religious cult which encouraged parents to set up their own little schools and renew their marriage vows, just like the Turpin family. I recognise some of their behaviours.

"When my parents got together they were disenchanted by the overly free and 'hippy' style of living that was sweeping across the country. They wanted children to live a different life instead of one with no morals or rules.

"They had heard about Bill Gothard, founder of the Institute in Basic Life Principles (IBLP), who was a really big deal in Oregon. They attended his seminars and embraced the IBLP homeschooling curriculum wholeheartedly.

"He was an icon, kind of like a prophet. The seminars involved a week of intensive brainwashing. He was the authority. His word was the law.

"My parents started homeschooling in the late 1980s and for over 30 years our family became part of this closed community with similar values."

'Strict and abusive'


"There was a lot of heavy-handed smacking from our parents. To disobey them, was to disobey God. The system was especially awful for the little ones. At Bill Gothard's seminars he used to talk about 'breaking their will'.

"They were quite abusive, but we knew other families who had it worse than us. When I was little, we lived in a mobile home. It was really inadequate - there were four or five of us in a room.

"Under the IBLP system, adults were not allowed to get into debt or have a mortgage, so my parents built a house. While it was being constructed we lived in a garage. I lived in a proper house at 15 and shared a bedroom with one or two sisters. It seemed fine at the time but as I grew up, it was more and more difficult having no space to myself."

Judy believes there is a connection between the Turpin family and Bill Gothard and the IBLP:

"He's very big in Texas. I met the Duggar family (who have 19 children) at one of the seminars. The real emphasis is on families, big ones."

'You don't know what's normal'


"The world outside our community was presented to us as an evil, bad place that we were protected from.

"We were required to memorise a lot of scriptures - chapters and chapters of the bible, to the point at which we could quote them off by heart.

"I got on with my siblings. You had to - that's one of the commands. I might not have in normal circumstances. There was definitely a pecking order and a lot of bullying in the family.

"Abuse in homeschool communities is often normalised or well-hidden and all too common.

"You don't know what's normal. There was no TV and no communication with anyone outside our circle. We watched movies once a week at our grandparents' house.

"We would have been seen and heard as there was a park and playgrounds near our house where we could play. But we didn't integrate outside the family."

'I was a second mum'


"We were fed well. All of us had braces on our teeth and we were healthy.

"I am the second eldest of nine siblings and when my mother gave birth I had childcare responsibilities.

"Girls weren't encouraged to pursue careers. They were expected to stay at home and help out with the family, and I was kept busy with lots of domestic work.

"I did pretty much everything. I was like a second mum, especially while my mum suffered from depression after she miscarried child number 10.

"My dad was away a lot on business during the spring and summer. But when he was around, he was most definitely in charge."
The outside world

"Under Bill Gothard's teachings, I was sent to Taiwan aged 21 to teach English for six months.

"After a year back in Oregon, I went to mainland China. In a sense, I didn't really leave my family. I was still very much connected by phone calls and emails.

"Living in China, I got to know 'normal' Americans who hadn't been homeschooled. That was a bit of a culture shock.

"I met a British man there and soon realised how different my life was back in Oregon. We decided to get married in the US."
Cutting ties

"I didn't realise how much of a hold the cult had on me. My husband and I stayed in the US for a while, but soon realised it was better for us to remove ourselves from the community completely. My family didn't really like my husband although he was really good with them.

"My husband encouraged me to stay in touch with my family. It took a lot for him to see that they were never going to change. But I have not seen my family since I left. I'm now in my 30s.

"A lot of people ask if it's hard to cut yourself off from your family. It was an upheaval but I was lucky to have the support of my husband who helped me to find the strength to leave my community and country. I couldn't have done it alone.

"It's taken me a long time to realise the extent of the abuse I encountered. Now that I have three lovely children of my own and am part of a real community and church, I realise my upbringing was not normal."

The Washington Post reported that Bill Gothard resigned from the IBLP ministry in 2014 amid allegations of sexual abuse, which he denied, and in 2016 there were further details of a lawsuit filed by 10 women.


Interview by Sherie Ryder, UGC and Social News team

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-42701297

Jul 5, 2017

Pupils 'at risk' in unregistered religious schools where children are 'beaten and study religious texts all day'

Parents claim their children are educated at home but they attend the school during the day
Inspectors discovered 286 unregistered schools in England. One in five are religion-based

Rachael Revesz
The Independent Online
July 3, 2017


Thousands of pupils are at risk in unregistered faith schools, according to the new Ofsted boss.
Amanda Spielman has called for new powers to protect children who are forced to study religious writings from the Koran, the Talmud and Torah and the Bible "full time".

"It is clear that weaknesses in current legislation allow some organisations to teach school-aged children religious texts full time ... and avoid proper scrutiny," Ms Spielman told The Sunday Times.

"Since January 2016 my inspectors have visited numerous establishments that they believe should be registered as schools. The fact that such places are able to operate and remain unregistered leaves pupils at risk."

Inspectors have discovered 286 unregistered schools in England over the past 18 months.

Less than half of them have been inspected, 36 have been issued warnings and the inspectors have not managed to gain access to the rest, The Sunday Times reported.

"We will do everything we can to make sure they comply with the law or are closed. But action is also needed to protect the children who attend these places," said Ms Spielman.

Up to 6,000 pupils are taught in unregistered centres. Some schools have closed, but none of the places Ofsted recommended for prosecution have come to court.

In one Hasidic Jewish school in Stamford Hill in North London, Talmud Torah Tashbar, former pupils told the newspaper about being hit with a stick for asking questions, having a finger broken or being forced to stuff chalk or soap in their mouths.

Many pupils are registered as home-educated but attend the school during the day.

The Department for Education said: "We have given Ofsted resources to step up investigations, identify them and work with us to take whatever action is required, including closing the school or working with the police and Crown Prosecution Service as necessary.

"There are already powers in place for local authorities and the police to safeguard children and intervene where they are not receiving a suitable education. We will support them in using these powers."

Ms Spielman, speaking last month at Wellington College after the spate of terrorist attacks in London and Manchester, said pupils should be taught "British values".

They should, she said, be given the "knowledge and resilience" to combat violent rhetoric from hate preachers who "put hatred in their hearts and poison in their minds".

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/pupils-children-risk-unregistered-faith-religious-schools-christian-jew-muslim-a7819731.html

May 19, 2017

Sharp rise in home-schooling for Montreal Hasidic children

Home-schooling is on the rise within Montreal's Hasidic community
English Montreal School Board will begin administering exams as part of agreement with parents

CBC News
May 12, 2017

The number of Hasidic children in Montreal being educated at home has jumped dramatically over the past two years, following a crackdown by the Quebec government on ultra-Orthodox Jewish schools.

There are currently 705 Hasidic children registered to be supervised by the English Montreal School Board. That is a threefold increase since 2015, said Angela Mancini, the school board's chair.

"When you're at 705 children, that's a school," Mancini told Radio-Canada. "That's like a small school."

The increase comes as Quebec education officials have been attempting to better regulate the schooling of Hasidic children, due to concerns that many attend schools that don't follow the provincial curriculum.

Last summer, a school in the Rosemont–La Petite-Patrie borough was raided by youth protection workers, escorted by police.

As part of the crackdown, the government has encouraged parents in the Hasidic community to sign home-schooling contracts with school boards.
To begin taking exams

The demand for such contracts has proven so great that the EMSB has had to hire additional staff. In addition, the school board will start administering French, English and math exams to home-school students.

"These are children who haven't written exams in the past. They don't have the same path as the students in our schools," Mancini said.

"The goal of the exams is really to ensure that the children have all the capacities, all the possibilities to succeed — to not put them in a failing situation."

Only certain students, at first, will write exams, but eventually all of them will, Mancini added. The long-term goal is to have the students write province-wide ministerial exams as well.

Many of the Hasidic children enrolled in home-schooling programs still attend private Orthodox schools, where they receive religious instruction. At home, they are taught standard subject matter.

At least one religious school, Yeshiva Toras Moshe Academy, has said it will help prepare its students for the school board exams.

"We obviously want to help them prepare," Jacob Maman, who heads the school's support services. "This is something different from what they've experienced in the past."

With files from Radio-Canada

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/sharp-rise-in-home-schooling-for-montreal-hasidic-children-1.4112118

Nov 10, 2016

Home-schooling rises sharply among Montreal's Hasidic families

KATHERINE WILTON
MONTREAL GAZETTE
November 9, 2016

 
Hasidic families
In the months after police and social workers raided an ultra-Orthodox Jewish school to investigate allegations of educational neglect, more than 400 Hasidic families have signed home-schooling contracts with the English Montreal School Board.

The board now has 654 Hasidic students being followed by teaching consultants who will track their progress to ensure they’re being taught the curriculum at home. Last year, the EMSB had home-schooling agreements with 236 Hasidic students.

The sudden increase means the EMSB will hire several employees and educational consultants who will meet with the students and their parents three times a year to evaluate their progress.

After the raid on the Vizhnitz community school on Parc Ave. last June, the Quebec government announced that it would increase the government subsidy for each home-schooled child to $1,000 from $616 for the 2016-17 school year.

The increased funding will allow the EMSB to set up a home-schooling team that will track the students’ progress and verify their school work. The students will also write government exams, but only after a two-year grace period.

Board spokesperson Michael Cohen couldn’t say whether it was the raid that led to the increase in families signing home-schooling contracts. However, he told the Montreal Gazette this week that the government had worked with the community and more of them are on board for home-schooling.

Most of the students covered by the agreements attend Yeshiva Toras Moshe Academy, an elementary school in Montreal, Vizhnitz school, a primary school in Montreal, and Beth Esther Academy, a primary and secondary school for girls in Outremont.

Youth protection officials closed their investigation over the summer after determining that there was no evidence of educational neglect.

“The observations and assessments demonstrate that your (children) are meeting developmental milestones,” Assunta Gallo, the director of youth protection for CIUSSS de l’Ouest-de-l’Île-de-Montréal, wrote in a letter to the community.

In an interview with the Montreal Gazette this week, Gallo said that while she can’t discuss details of the investigation, when youth protection officials close a file in cases like this one it’s because they have determined that the children are not compromised educationally. She said it’s not up to youth protection to ensure that students are following the education curriculum to the letter, but to make sure “they’re receiving the necessary schooling to become autonomous and to be able to function in their community.”

Quebec Education Minister Sébastien Proulx said in the wake of the June raid that the Hasidic community must balance the religious knowledge it wants to pass on with the secular instruction that all Quebec students are required to receive.

In November 2014, the government reached an out-of-court settlement with Yeshiva Toras Moshe Academy that allowed students to receive secular instruction at home while attending the school for religious lessons. The government previously tried to shut it down in 2010 because the teachers were not properly accredited and devoted only six hours of instruction a week to secular subjects.

Under the agreement, the Education Department will provide homework assistance and other services if parents of students attending Yeshiva Toras Moshe turn to home-schooling for their children’s secular education. Many students from that school are among those whose families signed home-schooling contracts with the EMSB last year.

Abraham Ekstein, a spokesperson for the Hasidic community, said signing the students up for home-schooling took time, but said the community had always intended to comply with the 2014 agreement.

He said that under the agreement, parents are responsible for educating their children at home, but added that tutors at the religious schools the children are attending teach them aspects of the curriculum during the school day.

During the 2014-15 school year, there were 1,300 home-schooled students in Quebec, according to the Education Department. The department says it does not know how many of those children are from ultra-Orthodox Jewish families.

Angela Mancini, the chairperson of the EMSB, said she thinks that more Hasidic families signed home-schooling contracts this year because the families that did so last year were happy with the set-up.

“People were comfortable with it and there was a certain trust,” she said. “The goal was to put the children in a situation where they are succeeding.”

kwilton@postmedia.com


http://montrealgazette.com/news/local-news/homeschooling-rises-sharply-among-montreals-hasidic-families

Jul 13, 2016

Quebec increases funding for homeschooling

CAROLINE PLANTE, MONTREAL GAZETTE

July 12, 2016

 

QUEBEC — The president of an organization representing Hasidic Jews in Outremont believes an additional $1 million for homeschooling this year is “very good news.”

Quebec’s education minister has announced he will double his department’s spending on homeschooling in 2016-17, bringing the government’s subsidy to school boards for each homeschooled child to $1,000 from $616. 

The decision comes as many parents in Montreal’s Hasidic community are turning to homeschooling to make sure they are complying with the education law.

About 300 Hasidic children from the Satmar and Viznitz communities are registered at the English Montreal School Board this year and will be homeschooled, the board said.

Many Hasidic and Orthodox schools are starting to go in that direction, said Alex Werzberger of the Coalition of Outremont Hassidic Organization (COHO) on Tuesday.

“This is a solution acceptable to both the government and the Orthodox community,” he said. “There has been a lot of friction between not-official schools (and the government) … but right now there seems to be a modus operandi accepted by everybody and it’s working.” 

The issue of illegal schools has confounded politicians in Quebec City for years, leaving many education ministers scratching their heads over what to do for the children.

There have been several police and youth protection raids of ultra-Orthodox schools over the years, with politicians each time saying the schools did not qualify as teaching establishments because they did not follow the Quebec curriculum.  

 

In November 2014, then-Education Minister Yves Bolduc reached an agreement with the Satmar community of Outremont that the government would provide homework assistance and other services if parents of Hasidic students turned to homeschooling.

 

This has allowed students to attend religious school during the day, and learn Quebec’s curriculum at home in the evening.

School boards are responsible for following up with students, checking their portfolios, and administering exams at the end of the year. 

EMSB chair Angela Mancini said that at first glance the new sums appear to be enough for the board to keep track of students’ progress — that is, if the number of students stays at 300. But Mancini said she is expecting more registrations this summer.

“The board, the administration is looking at it … will we need to hire more people? There’s a whole bunch of things being looked at,” she said.

The Parti Québécois said in a statement the problem remains unsolved.

“It certainly isn’t a sufficient solution to the larger problem of illegal schools,” said PQ MNA and leadership hopeful Alexandre Cloutier. “The education minister is trying to mask his government’s improvisation.”

Cloutier said the Liberals have tabled Bill 105, which re-opens the province’s Education Act, and nothing in the bill addresses the problem of illegal schools.

“We have no portrait of the situation, no report, no additional legislative tool which the minister himself admitted he needs to tackle the problem,” Cloutier added.  

“Meanwhile, hundreds of young Quebecers continue to be denied an education that is in line with the Education Department’s requirements.”

Education Minister Sébastien Proulx refused to be interviewed by the Montreal Gazette on Tuesday.

His press attaché, Marie Deschamps, said the additional sums, which were announced as part of this year’s budget rules, will be available to school boards across the province.

While applauding the new funding as a “step in the right direction,” Werzberger maintained his community will always “absolutely refuse” to teach the province’s religion and ethics course, as well as the sex education program. 

“Everybody wants their child to be educated … but they would like to have education which is acceptable to their religious and cultural requirements,” he said.

There were 1,300 homeschooled students in Quebec in 2014-15, according to the Education Department.

cplante@postmedia.com

twitter.com/cplantegazette

 

http://montrealgazette.com/news/quebec/quebec-to-invest-additional-1-million-into-homeschooling-this-year